The Easiest Whole Grain Seeded Bread

VGVDFNS
Jump to Recipe
Slices of simple homemade Whole Grain Seedy Vegan Bread with various toppings

My mom used to make her own bread and yogurt from scratch.

I mean, come on. How cool is she?

I remember learning that and thinking my mom was the most awesome hippie mom ever and I wanted to do the same if I was ever a mama.

The bread-making season in our house ended sometime around the arrival of 10-pound me. But can you blame her? She had two babies to look after and who has time to make bread with so much life happening?

Well, the good news is, you do have time to make this bread. I even speculate you could make it with a baby on your hip because it is literally a dump, mix, rise and bake kind of bread! Let’s get to baking!

Wood platter with ingredients for making super simple homemade vegan bread

This recipe is simple in both preparation and ingredients.

Just 9 basic ingredients that are very forgiving. If you don’t have any of the seeds or oats on hand, just omit them! It’s still totally doable.

Mixing together ingredients for making easy Vegan Whole Grain Seeded Bread

With a short 20-minute bake time, hands on prep time is only 15 minutes + the rise! Hello, free time.

When I say dump, mix, rise, I mean it.

You literally dump the ingredients in a bowl, mix and let it do its thing in the fridge.

Bread dough rising in a mixing bowl

All that’s left to do is knead in the seedy and oat-y things and let it rise once more while the oven preheats.

Twenty minutes later and you have a perfectly delicious, seedy, whole grain loaf on your hands.

Loaf of our simple homemade Whole Grain Seedy Vegan Bread that's perfect for making sandwiches
Freshly baked loaf of Whole Grain Seedy Vegan Bread in a bread pan
Partially sliced loaf of our homemade Seedy Vegan Bread recipe

This loaf is magnificent; everything you want in a homemade bread. It’s:

Seriously simple
Tender on the inside
Crusty on the outside
Loaded with whole grains
Seedy
Dreamy
& Perfect

This makes the perfect bread for toast, sandwiches, french toast, and everything in between.

I’ve been loving it with smashed avocado and a little vegan parmesan cheese and hemp seeds, or with peanut butter and flax seed. You really can’t go wrong.

Sliced homemade Whole Grain Vegan Seeded Bread perfect for making sandwiches

More Vegan Bread Recipes

If you give this recipe a try, let us know! Leave a comment, rate it, or take a picture and tag it #minimalistbaker on Instagram! We’d love to see what you come up with. Happy baking!

Slices of homemade bread with vegan butter, nut butter, avocado, and jam

The Easiest Whole Grain Seeded Bread

Easy, 9-ingredient seeded whole grain bread with oats, sunflower seeds, and flaxseed. Naturally sweetened, hearty, wholesome, and SO simple to make! Mix, rise, bake.
Author Minimalist Baker
Print
Partially sliced loaf of homemade Whole Grain Vegan Bread on a cutting board
4.81 from 467 votes
Prep Time 5 hours 15 minutes
Cook Time 30 minutes
Total Time 5 hours 45 minutes
Servings 12 (slices)
Course Bread
Cuisine Vegan
Freezer Friendly 1 month
Does it keep? 3-4 Days

Ingredients

Instructions

  • Combine warm water (like bath water, or 110 degrees F / 43 C), yeast, maple syrup (or other sweetener), salt, flaxseed meal, and flours in a large mixing bowl and stir. The result will be a sticky, rough dough. If using a stand mixer, beat at medium speed for about a minute. Otherwise just use a spoon to stir until well combined and when it can no longer do the job, knead and turn it in the bowl with your hands. Add flour until the dough is no longer sticking to the sides – about 3 3/4 cups total (amount as original recipe is written // adjust if altering batch size).
  • Lift the dough out and lightly grease the bowl with nonstick spray or olive oil. Cover and let rise for 2 hours at room temperature and 2 hours in the fridge. Alternatively, if you only have 2 hours, let rise at room temperature and skip the fridge (though a longer rise is best).
  • Use fingers to create a small hole in the dough and pour in sunflower seeds and oats. Transfer dough to a lightly floured work surface and knead about 20 turns or until elastic. Form into a loaf-like shape.
  • Place seam-side down in a lightly greased loaf pan or baking sheet and sift a light coating of flour over the top to help keep the dough moist. Loosely cover with plastic wrap and let rest for 45-60 minutes.
  • Preheat oven to 425 degrees F (218 C)* toward the end of the dough resting time and place a metal or cast iron pan (NOT glass, Pyrex, or ceramic) on the lowest oven rack. Also have 1 cup of hot water ready.
  • When the oven is preheated, slash the bread 2 or 3 times with a knife, making a cut about ½-inch deep.
  • Place in oven on middle rack. Then carefully pour hot water into the shallow pan on the rack beneath. Expect it to bubble and steam; then close oven door quickly.
  • Bake the bread for 26 to 35 minutes, or until deep golden brown and risen.
  • Remove the bread from the oven and let rest in the pan for 5 minutes. Then carefully remove from pan and transfer to a cooling rack to cool. Let it cool completely before slicing for best results (otherwise it can be doughy in the middle).
  • Store leftovers in a plastic bag at room temperature for up to a few days. Transfer to freezer for longer term storage.

Video

Notes

*Based on some users’ experience, I lowered the baking temperature to 425* F (from 450) to ensure the middle gets all the way done. I’ve had success at 450* F, but it seems some people’s ovens or loaf pans are not allowing it to cook all the way through. This information was updated 3/15/16.
*Adapted from my 7 Ingredient Muesli Bread.
*Nutrition information is a rough estimate.

Nutrition (1 of 12 servings)

Serving: 1 slices Calories: 169 Carbohydrates: 32.4 g Protein: 6.1 g Fat: 1.9 g Saturated Fat: 0.3 g Polyunsaturated Fat: 0.52 g Monounsaturated Fat: 0.36 g Trans Fat: 0 g Cholesterol: 0 mg Sodium: 294 mg Potassium: 124 mg Fiber: 4.2 g Sugar: 2.4 g Vitamin A: 0.73 IU Vitamin C: 0.02 mg Calcium: 18.86 mg Iron: 2.2 mg

This post was sponsored by the lovely folks at Bob’s Red Mill. Thanks for supporting the brands that support Minimalist Baker!

Did You Make This Recipe?

Tag @minimalistbaker on Instagram and hashtag it #minimalistbaker so we can see all the deliciousness!

If you love this recipe...

Get Our Fan Favorites eBook Here!

Reader Interactions

Leave a Comment & Rating!

Have a question? Use ctrl+f or ⌘+f on your computer or the "find on page" function on your phone browser to search existing comments! Need help? Check out this tutorial!

My Rating:




  1. Renee says

    I’ve tried to make bread using just gf 1 to 1 all purpose flour and let’s just say dense and brick description is putting it mildly!
    I LOVE your recipes and was so excited that I found a bag of Bob’s ww pastry flour in my pantry!!
    My question is…can I use Bob’s cup for cup (1to1) ap gf flour to sub ap flour??? I haven’t been out to the stores in 14days and have been ordering food supplies online. I’ve been out of bread for a couple days and would love to make this today (fingers crossed)!
    Thank you and Stay safe!!

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Hi Renee, we haven’t tried that, but it might be worth a try! Let us know how it goes!

    • Brittanie says

      Is there any way buckwheat flour could be used for the pastry flour? It’s a long shot but that’s all I’ve got ?

      • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

        We haven’t tried it, but maybe? It will probably be more dense. Let us know if you try it!

  2. Michelle says

    This bread is so delicious! I only needed 1 1/2 cups of the all purpose flour to get the dough just right. I will definitely be making this again!

  3. Bri says

    Good morning!
    I was wondering what your suggestion would be if I only had a ceramic or glass loaf pan to bake the loaf in? Thanks so much for your suggestion. Anxious to try the bread!:)

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerDana @ Minimalist Baker says

      That should work! I don’t anticipate you having any issues there. Let us know how it goes!

  4. Erica says

    I only have unbleached, enriched all purpose flour from Trader Joe’s, is that okay? I read the ingredients and it says “unbleached wheat flour”. Also, this recipe doesn’t need eggs, correct? I haven’t gone outside since the virus got really serious. And I’m forced to get groceries delivered! Please let know if that flour is okay, or if I need a different kind! Thank you!

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Hi Erica, no eggs in this recipe! That flour sounds more like the all purpose flour that we recommend using 1 3/4 cups of in this recipe. If you use also use all purpose for the 2 cups whole wheat flour, it will likely end up more light and fluffy like white bread. The whole wheat will make it more dense and nutty. Hope that helps!

  5. Amber says

    Thank you so much for the recipe! I’m so excited to try it!
    My question is .. would this work using a bread machine? I have a bread machine that I never used before and I’m hoping to give it a shot with your recipe! I’ve never made bread before and I’ve never used a bread machine. Going in blind! Lol

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Hi Amber, we haven’t tried it, but it should work. To see what other readers have tried, press “ctrl+f” on a PC or “command+f” on a mac and a find bar should pop up that allows you to search for specific words (such as “bread machine”) in the post and comments.

  6. Lauren says

    This was my first time making bread and it turned out amazing! I used active dry yeast, and bread flour + whole wheat flour because that’s what I had on hand. Will definitely make this again!

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Hi Liam, It will probably be more dense, but it might still work! Let us know if you try it!

  7. Vivian Arauz says

    I made this Bread today for my kids, they loved it and I too. This was our first time making hime made bread. We can find Bob Red Mill products here in ou country so this easy recipies are the best!!
    Thank you so much

    Regard from Panamá central america

  8. Don'L says

    The COVID-19 pandemic seemed the perfect time to learn to make bread! I want to follow this recipe but the emergency situation has motivated grocers to buy up all the Bob’s Red Mill Whole Wheat Pastry Flour in the store (out of stock online too, dang!). I have all-purpose Whole Wheat flour at home already though. Would that be okay as a substitute or can I adjust any other ingredients to somehow still be able to use the all-purpose?

    Thank you for posting this simple bread recipe! Once I get all the right ingredients I can’t wait to make it, haha!

  9. Kelsey says

    I have a question. I made this tonight and followed the instructions. It rose a bit longer perhaps 4.75 hours instead of 4 and I baked for the minimum 26 minutes. When I took it out of the oven it was dark golden brown on top but soft on the bottom. It is delicious but seems pretty dense, especially on the bottom. Do you think it needed more time in the oven or something else? I always seem to have this problem with bread, a bit dense on the bottom. Any troubleshooting would be appreciated!

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Hi Kelsey, is it possible your oven rack is not positioned in the middle of the oven? We would try playing around with placement! Otherwise, you could try covering with foil to see if that helps prevent browning on top. Hope that helps!

    • Veronique Horton says

      I had a similar experience. This time I let the bread stay in the full time, 35 minutes and I cover my bread with aluminum foil, halfway through the baking so it doesn’t overgrown

  10. Josh says

    This is the most delicious bread anyone in my household has had! Everyone loves it! I’m curious about what else can be added to this recipe such as dried fruits or anything else that’s been tried. Thanks for this recipe and all the others. I’ve tried so many vegan recipes from this site and they’re always simple and tasty.

  11. Sophie says

    I’m just making this now For tonight (and starting way too late!) and am confused by the rising options. If I only have about two hours it says to put it straight into the fridge and skip the room temperature rise. That seems counterintuitive? Wouldn’t it rise faster at room temp? Thanks for clarifying! Love your recipes.

  12. Kristel Holmes says

    I made this AMAZING bread last night for my family and again today for my in laws.
    The recipe is so easy to follow and the bread is AMAZING. This recipe will be our go to bread recipe for sure. I will definitely recommend this recipe to anyone! Thank you!

  13. Gabrielle says

    This was my first time making bread. I was out of almost all of the mixins, but did add chopped cranberries and oats. Oh my goodness, so delicious! My husband and I ate the whole thing in 3 days.

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerDana @ Minimalist Baker says

      Thanks for sharing, Gabrielle! Next time would you mind adding a rating to your review? It’s super helpful to us and other readers! xo

  14. Susan says

    Hello Dana (or anyone who knows the answer)! I am on lockdown in the San Jose Bay Area and would like to try this. I have all the ingredients except the instant yeast. I only have ActiveDry yeast. Can I substitute this in and if so, what modifications would I need to make to do this? Sorry, I am a novice bread baker but a very experienced, solid home cook. I would be very grateful for advice. Thank you!!

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Hi Susan, that should work! Just make sure to mix it with warm water and maple syrup and wait for it to bloom. Hope that helps!

  15. Jennifer Sheppard says

    HI!! This is my second attempt. 1st time my bread was VERY dry and didn’t rise well. I did everything right (or so I think). I must have went over the recipe for an hour before I had the courage to try it (I’m new to bread making and the reviews made it sound so easy). I did the 2 hour room temp rise and then put in the fridge for 2 hours. Dough was very dry/a little hard from being in the fridge and had hardly risen. I added my oats and seeds and it wasn’t happening. The dough was not working and the seeds were not able to be incorporated into the dough. Is it necessary to have a 4 hour rise with quick rise yeast (which is what I used?). I read a comment down below and you advised that a fridge rise is good if you want to pause or stop your rise. But the way the recipe is written (at least to me) it sounds like you need to do to 2 rises (1 at room temp and the other in the fridge). Can you clarify this? Can I just do a 2 hour room temp rise?

    Also wondering if you can use chia seeds and hemp seeds. I’m determined to figure this out and really hope I get it right the second time. : )

    Thanks so much!

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Hi Jennifer, the longer rise of 4 hours is preferable, but you can usually get away with just the 2 hour. For it being too dry, it sounds like it needs a little less flour next time. Make sure to add the last third of the flour a little at a time and stop when it feels firm enough. You may not need all of it.

  16. Maria says

    Hi there,
    I would like to make this bread.
    Can i use All purpose flour instead of unbleachflour

    I don’t like using unbleachflour.

      • Abby says

        What an awesome recipe!! I’ve made this twice for my family and both times it was a huge hit, gobbled up before the day was through! To that end, I’d really like to make a double recipe but I’m wondering if I need to make any alterations to the recipe when it is doubled?

        • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

          We’re so glad you enjoy it, Abby! This recipe should double well if you make two loaves. Let us know how it goes!

  17. daisy says

    I made this bread over the weekend and it turned out very well. I did substitute white pastry flour for the ww pastry flour, because that’s what I had on hand. I liked the process of being able to do a bit at a time, with the rising times coordinating perfectly within my day. It’s a wonderful bread to make on a weekend or a rainy day at home.
    Thanks, Dana!

    • Nina says

      My middle didn’t cook :( even with the new cooking instructions. I had to go longer and now its hard. Hmmm… I’ll try a different recipe another day. I am at 6,700ft. But most recipes I haven’t had to change much.

      • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

        Sorry to hear it didn’t turn out as expected, Nina! Altitude can be tricky. We aren’t super familiar with baking at altitude, but you could try lowering bake temp by 25 degrees and baking longer. Or you could also skip adding a pan of water underneath to help the bread dry more?

  18. David says

    Got a grain mill attachment for my mixer and decided to try this recipe using freshly ground hard white wheat and the last of my store bought all purpose flour. I got a good rise and it tastes wonderful. Thanks.

  19. Anne Cook says

    Wow Wow WOW!!! That is hands down the best bread I have baked. A recipe which is going to become a weekly thang ☺ I used 1/2 molasses for the sweetener and subbed some rye flour and kibbled rye. Oh my word I foresee me becoming very popular at shared lunches. Brilliant, easy peasy recipe thanks Dana

  20. Yogini says

    So disappointed. Spent 6-7 hours doing every single step, and my loaf is tiny, dense and inedible. What a waste of ingredients.

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Oh no! So sorry to hear that happened! So many others have had success with this recipe so we aren’t quite sure what might have gone wrong. Did you make any modifications? Were you baking at altitude? We’d love to help troubleshoot, if possible!

  21. Samantha F says

    Thanks for the amazing recipe. This is my first attempt at baking bread, since home ec class in middle school. I’ve used this recipe three times and each try gets even better. I look forward to trying more of your bread recipes!

  22. Valerie says

    Ok this is my First time ever making bread so I followed everything to a T, up until the water that’s supposed to go on the lowest rack on bottom of the bread. Our oven only has one rack so I used a cake pan, put the water in and put my pan with the bread dough in the center of that pan. My bread does not look exactly like yours but 80% close lol it is sooo sooo good Though! The crust is the perfect amount of toasty and the center is just heavenly! I wouldn’t want my loaves of bread tasting any differently and I’m impressed for this being my first attempt! Recommending this recipe to friends and family!

  23. Brian P. says

    My, almost, four year old daughter and I made this together. Omitted the sunflower seeds and added another tbps of oats. Everything else we kept the same; we used honey as our sugar.

    It turned out great!

    I’m not finding much on storage (for the next few days outside of the freezer. Any ideas?

    Thanks!!!

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerDana @ Minimalist Baker says

      Wonderful! Thanks for sharing. It will keep at room temp for several days, in the fridge up to 5 days, and in the freezer up to 1 month+.

  24. Taylor says

    I’ve been making this bread weekly – I’d like to figure out a way to make a gluten-free version for sharing. I see many replies below that this is on your list, so we’ll see if I get brave enough to try it on my own in the meantime…

    -I like that you can modify based on what you have in the pantry. I didn’t have any flaxseed meal or sunflower seeds the first time, and it turned out fine (though I’ve since been including these things).
    -I haven’t tried baking with steam in the oven yet, but I’ve gotten a pretty good crust without.
    -I usually end up using about 1/4 cup less all-purpose flour in the dough.

  25. Mary Bolla says

    Hi, I made dough with bread machine and then put in fridge for 2 hours. I am a novice break maker and this turned out good, but I am eager to do better next time as I sort of messed up on some of the directions here. One question I have is that the water in my cast iron was all gone by the time I checked the bread after 24 minutes of baking. Should I add more water to the pan so that it doesn’t completely evaporate during baking process? Is there magic to one cup of water? I have a large cast iron pan, so more surface area and 1 cup water doesn’t last very long. Also, I am not usually home all day long, so how important are the rising times? 2 hours room temp, 2 hours fridge, 45 min resting. It is easy, but you have to be around and paying attention . Also, I see that many breads ask for some type of fat – this doesn’t have any. Is there a reason why? Just trying to figure out the science of all of this. Thank you for such a lovely recipe!

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerDana @ Minimalist Baker says

      Hi Mary! Great question! I don’t find oil necessary in this recipe. But if you’d like to experiment, 1-2 Tbsp olive oil when adding the water could be nice.

      As for the water amount, feel free to add a little more! Especially if your pan is larger.

      As for the rise time, it isn’t too finicky. As long as it (approximately) doubles in size, you are good to go. If you want to stop or slow the rise, put in the fridge (like if you’d be away from home for a while).

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Hi Maggie, we haven’t tried that, but some other readers have. If you press “ctrl+f” on a PC or “command+f” on a mac, a find bar should pop up that allows you to search for specific words (such as bread machine) in the post and comments. Let us know if you give it a try!

  26. Laura Simmons says

    My first time baking bread. What flour could I substitute the WW flour with? Its better that I avoid wheat. Am excited to try this recipe!! Thank you!

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Hi Laura, we haven’t tried a gluten-free version of this bread, but we have it on our list to attempt a gluten-free bread! Stay tuned!

  27. Barney says

    Definitely a keeper. Three modifications. I added 1/3 cup of unprocessed bran. I did have to add a little more water (maybe 1/4 cup). Just trying to get a little more fiber in it. I also used active dry yeast, didn’t have the rapid rise, besides, I don’t like it anyway – less flavor. The 3rd modification is baking it in my oven under convection at 400F for 30 minutes. Turned out perfectly. This bread is dead easy and delicious. Next time I think I’ll add the oats and sunflower seeds at the beginning.

  28. Sherrie says

    I’m having a problem understanding the rising instructions , do you put the bread in the fridge or room temperatures or 2 hours for rising or do both ?????

  29. Susan says

    Just made this…turned out awesome! Very easy, great instructions! I used regular whole wheat flour instead of pastry flour, still turned out great. I have never had a lot of luck making bread. Something always seems to go wrong. If I can make this, anybody can! Will definitely be making again!

  30. Amanda says

    Love this bread but had trouble getting it baked all the way through. I doubled the recipe and made two loaves, one in a bread pan baked 33 mins, and one on a sheet pan baked 28 mins. The one on the sheet pan was perfect, excellent flavor, crumb and crust. However the one in the loaf pan, though very nicely browned and appearing done, had a very gummy interior.
    I did make one change to original recipe which was using stone ground spelt flour, at a ratio of 1 3/4 cup with 2 cups AP flour. I think this ratio worked well as the end result was not too dense.
    If I make again I will try baking the loaf at 400° for 45 min

  31. Maria Roelle says

    I make this regularly now. My family loves it. I put the seeds in during the mixing process and leave out oats but add a tsp of ground rosemary and 2 Tbsp of “Everything Bagel” seasoning. Omg. Yummo

  32. Mindy says

    I’ve made this bread twice in one week. It is super simple and my family loves it. Both times that I have made it, I only did a two hour rise and not another two hours in the fridge. It turned out perfectly.

  33. Kelly says

    Hi! Is it possible to replace the unbleached white all purpose flour with wholemeal flour? Also, is it possible to use all purpose wholemeal flour instead of pastry flour? I prefer to eat only whole meal flour as it makes me more full. Your help would be really appreciated!

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Hi Kelly, the wholemeal flour will make it more dense, but if you don’t mind that, it might work. Pastry flour is preferred, but it might work with all purpose wholemeal. Let us know if you do some experimenting!

  34. Sally says

    Hi,
    I’m not usually a review leaver and I’m generally sour dough mad, but I made this for easy bread rolls and oh my god did these deliver.
    I admit, I made some minor tweaks (no flax, used quinoa, added caraway seed tsp and 2tbs sesame seeds) but this bread is beautiful. Light, fluffy and a good crust that isn’t too chewy.
    You are a breadmaking deity and I bow at your altar.

  35. Jordan says

    This bread is so good! Made it twice now and it is my new favorite healthy sandwich bread. Both times turned out wonderful – the first whole wheat bread I’ve found that I can actually get to rise. And I did once make it with a baby (well, toddler) on my hip!

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Thanks so much for the lovely review, Jordan. We are so glad you enjoyed it! Next time, would you mind leaving a rating with your review? It’s super helpful for us and other readers. Thanks so much! Xo

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Hi Estelle, the yeast needs sugar to activate. You might be able to reduce it, but we wouldn’t recommend omitting.

  36. Mireille says

    Thanks so much Dana for another amazing recipe! I made this bread yesterday (my very first bread ever!) and I’m so pleased with the result! Just a great homemade multigrain bread! Yay!! :)

  37. Mindy Richmond says

    I received a bread maker at our office Christmas party raffle. Have you made any of your vegan breads in a bread maker?

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      We haven’t, but other readers have done so with success! We’d love to hear if you do some experimenting! If you press “ctrl+f” on a PC or “command+f” on a mac, a find bar should pop up that allows you to search for specific words in the post and comments to see what others have done.

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      We haven’t tried it and aren’t sure. But, we have it on our list to make a gluten free loaf of bread. Stay tuned!

  38. Laurie Bozek says

    Wo you think this recipe work in my bread machine or would the machine’s dough only cycle over-knead the bread and make it tough?

  39. Paul says

    I haven’t tried this recipe yet, but I don’t understand why one would put dough in the fridge to proof. Cold retards the rise. Is this a misprint?

    • Eden says

      I let it rise on the counter with fine results. Two hours on the counter, then deflate the dough. Shape it, and put it in a bread loaf pan. Let rise until it is substantial enough in size. Then pop it in the oven.

  40. Claudia says

    The dough was too dry the first two times I tried this recipe. Then I followed the directions and added the last third of the flour a little at a time and stopped when I thought it was firm enough. I also had trouble with the second knead. The dough seemed to tear too much, and I never really felt that it got elastic. However, the second rise was quite nice and the bread was excellent.

  41. Dina says

    I finally made a bread that didn’t turn out to be a door stop!
    Thank you for this recipe. I made my own whole wheat pastry flour using sprouted spelt flour mixed with tapioca starch and blended that with Einkorn all purpose flour. That’s what I had on hand, and it turned out great! Crispy crust, soft inside.
    Followed the rest of the recipe as written. Can’t wait for toast tomorrow!

  42. Jack says

    Thank you for this. Is it okay to make this without the oats? Will it still work without oats? Oats always screw up my stomach.

  43. Asli says

    Turned out fantastic and my mother loved it! Moist in the inside and crusty on the outside. Exactly how it is described :) I used half wholemeal flour and half white flour. Best bread recipe I have used so far :)

  44. Barry says

    Awesome recipe! Have made a few times always great. Nothing like the smell of fresh bread baking and straight to your plate! I use organic flour, whole wheat and all purpose, half and half, some honey and salt for flavour and whatever I have around for seeds and such. Only problem it never lasts too long and I don’t mean spoilage! Lol Great easy recipe to fool around with have some fun with it!

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerDana @ Minimalist Baker says

      Ha! Thanks for sharing, Barry! Next time would you mind adding a rating to your review? It’s super helpful to us and other readers! xo

  45. Nancy says

    This is my go to recipe.I haven’t bought sandwhich bread for couple of months now.I skip the water in pan.It turns out great.I’ve making extra batches and storing in freezer.I slice at least 2 batches.It takes about 10-15 minutes to defrost. Thanks for the recipe!

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Thanks so much for the lovely review, Nancy. We are so glad you enjoyed it! Next time, would you mind leaving a rating with your review? It’s super helpful for us and other readers. Thanks so much! Xo

  46. Jennifer Scott says

    So good! I didn’t have pastry flour, just whole wheat. We mill our own. I used half spelt and half red winter wheat. I sifted the wheat and added 4 tbsp cornstarch to make it closer to pastry flour (I read that this was a good modification for whole wheat when pastry flour was called for), and then in the end kneaded in some of the sifted out bran with the oats instead of seeds because I didn’t have any. I also sprinkled a few herbs on top. Came out crispy on the outside, soft on the inside, and delicious!
    My new go- to bread recipe!

  47. Cody says

    I have made this recipe twice and both times the outside was thoroughly cooked but the inside was very doughy and dense. The first time I tried cooking at 425 F for 24 minutes, the second time I tried 450 F for 26 minutes, but got similar results. I live in Denver so I am trying to adjust for high altitude by adding 1/3 cup more water and about 2 tbsp more of flour. This time I am planning to cook at 475 F for around 20 minutes. Even though it comes out doughy the bread itself tastes really good, I just need to figure out what’s going on. Also I am using a breadpan but I’ve seen other people suggest using an open tray. Any advice?

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerDana @ Minimalist Baker says

      Hmm, altitude can be tricky. I’m not sure what else to try as this isn’t our area of expertise. But you could try lowering bake temp by 25 degrees and baking longer.

      You could also skip adding a pan of water underneath to help the bread dry more?

  48. Joanna says

    I made two loaves this weekend and we gobbled them up just toasted with butter. First loaf just oats, second was just seeds. The seedy one was tastier IMO. I’m thinking of measuring dry ingredients (minus yeast) into containers so I can just dump and mix in the future. A fun weekend of bread experiments- thank you!

  49. Paul McCann says

    Everyone loves this bread. I make it two or three times a week. I am type one diabetic and when eating it, it does not raise my blood sugar numbers like store bought bread, which is great. I have modified a few things, I dump everything into the mix bowl, let it work it for about two minutes and let it rise right in the bowl for 2 – 3 hours, punch it down and then put it into loaf pans for an hour and a half, then into the oven. 425 degrees for 33 mins and out it comes, the best. Nothing smells quite like homemade bread baking in the oven. Also, I use two cups of Robinhood Wholegrain flour and one cup of unbleached white flour, it works the best for us and our friends.

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Thanks so much for the lovely review and for sharing your modifications, Paul. We are so glad you enjoy it! Next time, would you mind leaving a rating with your review? It’s super helpful for us and other readers. Thanks so much! Xo

  50. Charissa says

    I made with 1/2 whole wheat and 1/2 regular unbleached flour. Worked great. And to encourage you– with twin 3 year olds helping. This is easy for me, new to baking bread, and easy for my kids who love participating. The low-labor check ins are enough to build interest from young bakers, and simple enough they can help. The fast baking time means they don’t have to wait too long to taste it!

  51. Marjorie says

    Delicious bread, I love it !!!!!! Any ideas of other seeds that we can combine other the oats? Can we keep the bread in something other than a plastic bag ?

    Thank you ☺️

  52. Lindsey says

    I used my bread machine to make this bread. It is delicious. I would be prettier if I used the dough cycle and baked in the oven. I may do that next time, or not. Anyway, I love it. It toothsome and hearty, perfect for avocado toast or open face PB& J.

  53. HK says

    DELICIOUS. The initial mixture of flour/salt/flax and liquids was a little dry so I added extra water so I could get about 3.5 cups of flour in. I used honey, which is more viscous than maple syrup, so that’s probably why. I also used pepitas instead of sunflower seeds just because that’s what I had. It turned out really well! It’s very hearty and filling. Can’t wait to try it out with sandwich fixins.

  54. Rachel says

    Can you make this for a bread machine? It sounds yummy and I already love bread with all of those ingredients! Please say yes ☺️

  55. Elena says

    Awesome recipe! This is absolutely one of my favorite bread recipes. Love the down time!!! I also tried adding pepper flakes and dried basil (both organic) to the second loaf – result was delicious :)

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Hi Melanie, It will affect the flavor and make the texture more dense. But yes it should work!

  56. Alexandra says

    I used 2 cups regular all-purpose flour in place of pastry flour and 1.5 cups sprouted whole wheat, omitted sweetener, used pumpkin seeds instead of sunflower seeds (by mistake) and added 1-2tbs whole flax seeds. Otherwise followed your recipe to the T, it was incredible! Juicy and crunchy and yummy, my boyfriend was so impressed! I’ve never made *good* whole wheat bread before, so thank you! Will save this recipe and make again! PS this makes 1 loaf n i cooked it for nearer 40 mins

  57. Alexandra says

    I used 2 cups regular all-purpose flour in place of pastry flour and 1.5 cups sprouted whole wheat, omitted sweetener, used pumpkin seeds instead of sunflower seeds (by mistake) and added 1-2tbs whole flax seeds. Otherwise followed your recipe to the T, it was incredible! Juicy and crunchy and yummy, my boyfriend was so impressed! I don’t think I’ve ever successfully made whole wheat bread without it being super dense before, so thank you! Will save this recipe and make again! PS this makes 1 loaf n i cooked it for nearer 40 mins

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Thanks so much for the lovely review, Alexandra. We are so glad you enjoyed it! Next time, would you mind leaving a rating with your review? It’s super helpful for us and other readers. Thanks so much! xo

  58. Chris says

    Sorry but this is a fail for no taste. The bread looks nice and smells nice but it has no taste. Like really bland, chewing carpet taste. Try adding more salt, or other ingredients because the instructions are really great. No offense.

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Hi Chris, sorry to hear you didn’t enjoy this recipe. We are surprised since so many people have commented that they enjoy the flavor! Did you by chance make any modifications?

  59. Donna Buchholz says

    Made this for my newly vegan daughter last night with dinner (vegan lasagna). Made a wonderful huge loaf that fed 8 and the few leftovers were fought over by the group as to who gets to take them home. I had to share this recipe with them via text. A keeper!

  60. Rachelle says

    This bread came out amazing!! I’m trying to restrain myself from eating the entire loaf. I only used regular wheat flour since I didn’t have pastry flour. Mmmmm. It baked up beautifully. The recipe was ridiculously easy to follow. I definitely will be making more soon!

  61. Joseph K says

    Followed this recipe almost exact.. except I used ground chia instead of flax
    Also I used bobs whole wheat bread flour instead of pastry flour ..
    Came out fantastic!
    The recipe was very clear and easy to follow and the bread was crusty golden brown with soft spongy center the whole house smelled great!! Just a lovely ? bread
    Thanks ? so much for sharing this recipe !

  62. Mikayln B says

    Question: would it be okay to omit the pastry flour? I don’t know if bread making is going to become a regular thing for me so I don’t want to buy it if it’ll go to waste. Hope to try this soon, and thank you! :)

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerDana @ Minimalist Baker says

      Yeah! I think just go with regular whole wheat flour or white whole wheat flour! Let us know how it goes.

  63. Mae says

    Hi! I have a rice cooker, yes, rice cooker, haha, that has a “cake” cook option. Do you think this recipie would work for it? Thanks.

  64. Joel B says

    I usually make it using commercial fast-acting yeast but I was wondering how to do it using my own wild yeast made from this site. Would it work? Could you help in telling me how to proceed and what quantity to use? Thanks again. Take bread is so amazing!

  65. Laurie says

    I have been seeing recipes that call for baking in a covered casserole, do you think this would work that way too? Either way, I’m going to give this bread at try, it sounds great! Thanks for the share

  66. Robina says

    I want to know what is the difference between whole wheat flour & whole wheat pastry flour. Isn’t same as whole wheat flour?

      • Lisa says

        That isn’t the difference, pastry flour is a low protein flour that is better suited for biscuits, scones and pie crusts, bread flour is high in protein. Not sure what difference it would make in your bread recipe.

  67. Kyle says

    Hi, I was making this recipe and I wasn’t sure if I did step one correctly. Don’t really have any experience baking. After adding the yeast, honey, salt, flax seed etc… I started to add the flour. I added the 2 cups whole wheat flour first and mixed it in, then I added the 1 3/4 cup white flour. Not all of the white flour seems to want to mix in. Should I have mixed the wheat and white flour together before pouring them into the main mixture?

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerDana @ Minimalist Baker says

      That’s a good question! There should be enough liquid to combine them either way, so it shouldn’t matter much. But if you want you can mix the flours together prior to mixing, sift them in, or alternate white and wheat as you add them. Hope that helps!

  68. Daisy says

    Thank you for this simple, yet awesome recipe. I made this using a red hard wheat and unbleached white pastry flour with 2 tablespoons of additional gluten to increase the fluffy factor. I also added 1/4 of hemp seeds in addition to the sunflower seeds. It came out so lovely.
    Let me say, as a former pastry chef I am very impressed with your recipes. I’ve been using them and impressing family and friends for years with your creativity. And as a long time vegan, I also appreciate that I can share your site with folks looking for healthy, easy to follow vegan entrees, side dishes and desserts.
    Cheers! Daisy in Seattle

    • Dylan says

      I am in the middle of the final rise of the second loaf in two days. Lol! The whole family loves it. I used it as a base, I went up to 2 cups of water and added some buckwheat and rye flours. I also went up a bit on the seeds, just because I like a seedy bread.

  69. Leslie says

    Question: we’re trying to do the WFBP thing and I’m wondering if there’s any reason I couldn’t use 100% whole wheat flour? Doesn’t it change the texture?

  70. Cynthia says

    Can we use 2 packet of yeast and also give it more time to rise to make the bread lighter? The bread looks kinda dense… Thanks in advance.

  71. Pauline Jones says

    This was the BEST whole wheat bread I have ever made! I was skeptical at the lack of fat and/or eggs, but this bread baked up so tender and moist! I added some chia seeds to the mix and only let it rise till doubled the first time (about an hour), then about 45 minutes in the pan. I did use the pan of water while baking, which I had never done for bread before. I will DEFINITELY be making this bread again & again! Thank you!!

  72. Elena says

    This is my go to bread recipe. It always comes out perfect. When it’s cooled off I slice it and freeze it for later. Tastes like fresh out of the freezer too. Thanks for this great recipe!

  73. michelle grant says

    Would it work with a mix of brown rice flour, quinoa flour and coconut flour :) and instead of yeast – lemon use and baking soda substitute?

    Will try it at the weekend and feedback!

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Hi Michelle, we aren’t sure how that would turn out. We look forward to hearing about your experimentation! Thanks!

  74. Carie says

    This is truly a no fail bread recipe. I have made it twice now, both time with whole wheat flour, not pastry flour and honey. I doubled the recipe, made 3 loaves. I let it rise on my room temp counter top covered with a towel for 2 hours, then knead in the oats and seeds, then I pop it into the loaf pans and let it rise again until it is the height I like, about 1 hour plus oven heating time. I over with towels there too. One time I made it with the pan of water and one time without. The time without had a crispier, thicker crust which I preferred. It was so easy to make! The bread is dense, but not heavy. Slices really well for sandwich bread and is a 100% hit with my house! THANK YOU!

  75. Jenny says

    This is a delicious and easy recipe to follow. I use personally milled whole wheat flour and add some lemon juice (a couple tablespoons), which helps to bring it the flavour. This is our way weekly bread! Thank you, Dana!

    • Katie says

      Thank you for this recipe! I make it almost weekly in our house and it’s easy and delicious. I like letting the dough rise in then fridge overnight if I’m busy the day before. A long rise with whole wheat bread seems to give it a richer flavor. I also like it best with maple syrup for the sweetener.

  76. Anna Behnke says

    I loved making this bread! It was my first time making real bread instead of quick breads and I was really pleased with the results. I have to admit I cut a few corners with the proofing. I didn’t allow enough time after work before I went to bed, but it still turned out great! Based on my “expert” opinion (from watching all episodes of the Great British Baking Show lol), I can tell I definitely underproofed and also underbaked it a little. I did an hour at room temperature and 1 hour in the refrigerator followed by the 60 minute second proof at room temperature in the form and a 30 minute bake. I also added a few different fillings. I did chopped walnuts, rolled oats, pepitas, and chopped dates. I’m so happy I tried this bread and I’ll definitely be following more posts :)

  77. Jenny says

    This recipe did not work for me. I left some flour aside for the step which seemed to require kneading flour into the dough. I let it rise on the counter for two hours and in the fridge for two hours, then the kneading/shaping/proofing before baking. After 26 minutes, the outside of the bread was very brown – but the inside was still raw!

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Hi Jenny, sorry to hear this didn’t work out for you! Is it possible that your oven runs warm? You could try reducing the heat or let it sit in the oven with the heat off at the end to help the inside bake more. Hope that helps!

  78. Elena says

    This really is a delicious bread recipe. Simple and so good. I used whole wheat flour and all purpose flour and it turned out really great. I should let it cool though before cutting, but it just looked too good to wait!

  79. Meghan L Donahue says

    Hi, I’m looking forward to making this this evening, but don’t have time to go to the grocery store. I have white all-purpose flour, white bread flour, whole wheat flour, buckwheat flour, vital wheat gluten, almond flour and semolina flour. What combination is the best substitute as I don’t have the pastry flour?

    Thanks,
    Meghan

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Hi Meghan, we aren’t sure if it would work without the whole wheat pastry flour. However, of those options, we think whole wheat flour would be the best substitute. It may turn out more dense. If you give it a try, we would love to hear how it goes!

      • Meghan says

        It turned out really well. Last night I did the recipe with honey and wheat flour instead of wheat pastry flour. I made sure to prewarm my mixer bowl and the water was 113 degrees. I let it rise 2hrs on the counter (kitchen was 72 degrees) and then I put it in the fridge with a towel over it overnight (recipe said 2hrs, but I didn’t want to stay up). That dried it out a little when kneading, and next time I’ll use plastic wrap. This morning I kneaded in some sunflower seeds I toasted last night and 2 tbs of 5 grain cereal. I had to let it rest for about 2.5hrs to get it to rise nicely in the pan, this is likely because of the wheat flour? Anyways, it turned out perfect, nice and light in the slices and not crazy dense. I enjoyed the coveted heels for a snack with my lunch and then I’ll take the rest to the dinner party. It’s all sliced up and ready to go! I’d send pictures, but we can’t upload them.

  80. Bri says

    This was my first time making bread and it came out so yummy. I’m a teenager trying to teach myself how to cook and even though I wasn’t really sure how to kneed the dough I was able to figure it out make a great bread that my family really liked.

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      We are so glad to hear you enjoyed this recipe, Bri! So lovely that you are learning to cook! Happy cooking xo

  81. Ellie says

    Just curious why this dough is supposed to go in the fridge? Most bread recipes encourage you to leave dough in a warm place. The colder the temperature, the longer the bread will take to rise. If you’re going to skip one of the 2-hr rises, wouldn’t it make more sense to let it rise on the counter for two hours and skip the 2nd rise (in the fridge)?

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Hi Ellie! It could probably sit at room temp the whole time but I wouldn’t exceed 3 hours or it will likely rise over your bowl.

      • Jenni says

        I am just making the bread now but I had the same concern about putting it in the refrigerator, too. I’ll try it because of the good reviews stating that it works but I always thought warm places make the dough rise. What is the science of putting the dough in the refrigerator?

        • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerDana @ Minimalist Baker says

          If it rises in the refrigerator it allows for a slower more methodical rise, versus a quick one which happens in a warmer environment. Hope that helps!

          • Jenni says

            Thank you! BTW, it turned out great! I will be marking it again. I baked it at 425 degrees like your later comment suggests. I really am trying to go plastic free so I’m trying to bake more. Better ingredients and less plastic bags!

      • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

        Hi Roro, the flaxseed doesn’t act as an egg here, so we would recommend either subbing it with another seed or leaving it out. Hope that helps!

  82. Keith Wollman says

    I’ve made this three times and it is one of the best loaves I’ve made. Has anyone experimented with more/different types of seeds? Does it change the recipe?

    • Avatar for Dana @ Minimalist BakerSupport @ Minimalist Baker says

      Using different/more seeds should work out well, Keith! Just be sure to not add to much more or you might find that the bread will have a hard time holding form when cutting..

  83. Jacque says

    I love this recipe. I make a few changes / omissions every time because I bake with four small children under my feet. But it always turns out well. And holds up to lots of ‘kneading’ and ‘flouring’ from said small children. I also prefer it when the cooking time is up and I turn off the oven and just leave it in there for a couple hours. This happened by mistake a few times after turning it off while nursing a baby and forgetting the bread. But I think it turned out really well from that!

  84. Peggy Williams says

    This is the best! My whole family loves it. I make it every week. Thanks for sharing this easy, wholesome, & delicious recipe.