What’s fall without a good seasonal sugar cookie? I’m glad you agree. Onto the dough!
These cookies were inspired by fall, first and foremost, but also by my 1-Bowl Vegan Funfetti Cupcakes!
I overfilled the muffin tins with batter on my first try and quickly realized that the overflow baked perfectly into a sugar cookie-type consistency! In that moment, I knew vegan sugar cookies were not far out of reach.
This recipe is easy and fast! Just 1 bowl, simple methods, and 1 hour start to finish (frosting and all). And they just so happen to taste like the sugar cookies of your youth, just without (real) butter, eggs, or milk. Huzzah!
And what would a sugar cookie be without frosting?
I’ve included a basic vegan buttercream recipe below that’s infused with pumpkin butter and fall spices. It makes the perfect addition to these fluffy gems and sends the pumpkin flavor over the top.
You’re going to love these cookies. They’re:
Tender
Fluffy
Slightly crisp on the edges
Pumpkin-y
Subtly spiced
Perfectly sweet
Amazing with pumpkin buttercream
Satisfying
Simple
& Shareable
What are you waiting for? No seriously?
If you make this recipe, let us know! Leave a comment, tweet at us, or take a picture and tag it #minimalistbaker on Instagram!
We have more than 2,200 #minimalistbaker tags so far and we see every single one! We love seeing what you guys create, so keep it up! And as always, thanks for supporting what we do. Cheers!
- 1/2 cup (1 stick) vegan butter (such as Earth Balance), softened*
- 1/2 cup organic cane sugar + more for topping
- 1/4 cup brown sugar
- 1 tsp pure vanilla extract
- 1/4 cup pumpkin puree (or sub pumpkin butter and hold back 1 Tbsp of cane sugar)
- 1 1/2 cups + 1 Tbsp unbleached all-purpose flour (sub up to 1/3 whole-wheat pastry)
- 1/2 Tbsp cornstarch or arrowroot powder (for thickening/binding)
- 1 tsp baking powder
- 1/2 tsp baking soda
- 1/4 tsp salt
- 1 teaspoon pumpkin pie spice
- 3/4 tsp ground cinnamon
- 1 Tbsp unsweetened almond milk (or other non-dairy milk)
- 1/2 cup (1 stick) vegan butter, softened
- optional: 1 1/2 Tbsp pumpkin butter*
- optional: 1/2 tsp vanilla extract
- 2 1/2 - 3 cups powdered sugar
- 1/4 tsp each ground cinnamon and pumpkin pie spice
- Splash non-dairy milk
- Add softened butter to a large mixing bowl and cream with a mixer for 1 minute.
- Add sugar, brown sugar and vanilla and beat for 1 more minute. Add pumpkin and mix once more.
- Set your sifter over something that will catch fall out and add dry ingredients. Use a spoon to briefly stir, then sift over butter and sugar ingredients, to combine.
- Mix until until incorporated, being careful not to over mix. Then add almond milk and mix until a soft dough is formed. Freeze dough for 15 minutes, or refrigerate for 30 minutes (or chill overnight), preheat your oven to 350 degrees F (176 C), and position a rack in the center of the oven.
- Scoop out heaping 1 Tbsp amounts of dough and roll into balls. Place on a clean baking sheet 2 inches apart to allow for spreading. Dip a glass into cane sugar and then gently smash the cookie ball down into a disc (see photo).
- Bake on the center rack for 10-12 minutes or very slightly golden brown.
- Let rest on pan for a few minutes. Then transfer to a cooling rack to cool completely. Prepare frosting in the meantime.
- FOR FROSTING: Wipe/rinse your mixing bowl clean and add softened butter. Beat until light and fluffy. Then add vanilla, spices, and pumpkin butter (optional) and mix once more.
- Add powdered sugar 1/2 cup at a time and continue mixing until thick and creamy. Drizzle in a little non-dairy milk to thin. You want this frosting to be pretty thick so it will hold its shape once on the cookies, so only add a little milk and add more powdered sugar if it gets too thin.
- Once cooled, frost cookies and top with a sprinkle of pumpkin pie spice or cinnamon. Store leftovers covered at room temperature for up to a few days. Freeze for longer-term storage.
*If you are trying to speed-soften your butter, simply cut it into thin slices from the stick and it will soften much quicker.
*Pumpkin Butter recipe can be found at Oh She Glows. Or you can use store-bought.
*Loosely adapted from my Vegan Funfetti Cupcakes!
These look dreamy! Sugar cookies are definitely an important part of fall, so these cookie are a must on my list!
Can I follow this recipe but use real butter and milk?
I did and used an egg instead of tapioca. It still worked great! So light. Yum!
This looks amazing! I’m going to make these.
Dana- You and I must think alike! I had a friend over 2 days ago and made your ginger cookies but instead of orange zest and orange juice (in the buttercream frosting/filling) we used pumpkin spice. Our cookies turned out pretty much like these!
Keep up all the delicious recipes!
-Anne
Thanks Anne! Sounds like you beat me to the awesomeness that is pumpkin cookies!
These are so cute! That texture looks perfect. Love the bright orange board in your pics – so fun! Pinnnnnnned.
Aaaah I agree, they are so cute! Looks gorgeous as always – and love the handmodelling going on there :)
WOW- these look soooooo good! Can’t wait to make them :D
I absolutely LOVE sugar cookies with frostings… yum yum yum. Pumpkin isn’t such a big spice and flavour to bake with in the UK, and I’m really missing it.
Sad day. Good thing it’s really easy to mix yourself! Just combine cinnamon, ginger, allspice, cloves and nutmeg!
Vegan Pumpkin Lofthouse Cookies! These look outrageously good — and perfect for the season. Thanks for sharing!
Those cookies look so good!
I just made these and the batter is so good I barely had any left to bake cookies!
ha! Good problem to have!
I love cookies of any kind and these are just perfect for fall! Vegan, even better! The frosting is delicious, as I’ve made very similar one for cupcakes.
These look totally awesome Dana! I love the sound of adding frosting – there is never too much pumpkin!!
These look absolutely delicious! I’ll try these soon!
xx
These remind me of those old slice and bake cookies from the refrigerator section at the shop. Love the seasonal take on them. That orange hue is just gorgeous as well. Halloween party-worthy!!!
I have been searching for the perfect way to use my new Earth Balance buttery sticks. Score.
These were a hit with my in-laws. Again, score.
Wow, I can’t wait to try this recipe ! They look absolutely delicious. !
Alexandra Marie
I’ve always made and frosted seasonal sugar cookies… but I’ve never thought about actually flavoring them to match the season! Guess my halloween cookies this year will actually fit the holiday :)
I love fall recipes, and these look perfect!!
Is there anyway to get the nutritional information for this recipe? :)
Sorry about that! I’ll add it later today.
Pumpkin butter sounds perfect for fall! Why haven’t I heard of it before!
Wow! I am totally going to try these they look delicious! And they look so soft I could sink my teeth into one of these right now! Yummm pinning these babies!
I really want to make these but have no vegan butter on hand. Would it be possible to use soft coconut oil?
I think so, but I can’t guarantee the results. Check back if you do!
I just wanted to share my results using coconut oil in place of the vegan butter. They came out FANTASTIC! The dough gets soft if you don’t handle it quickly but I had no real problems. I rolled mine in sugar/pumpkin pie spice and then flattened them on a parchment lined cookie sheet. I bake exactly 10 minutes and let them cool about 2 minutes once done. They don’t look quite as perfect as the ones pictured but they are super soft and delicious! Thanks for a great recipe. My kids are in heaven :)
Awesome! I was scrolling through seeing if this was possible. I don’t use vegan butter but I’m going to try mine now with coconut oil!
I also subbed the 1/2 c butter for 1/2 c refined coconut oil with good results. The cookies were on the cakier side, and while I prefer chewy cookies they were still very good! I will try these again sometime with the butter to compare the texture.
Also, I freezed the dough for the recommended 15 minutes and was worried when it came out slightly frozen on top, but the cookies turned out beautifully. In fact they came out very similar to the pictures which NEVER happens so I was quite pleased !
Thanks for the recipe !
Thanks Caitlin! Thanks so much for sharing!
Dana,
If I don’t have cane sugar, can I use regular sugar or will that create a problem?
Nope! That works!
Just tasted these yummy little guys….SOOOOOO GOOODDDD!!! My roommate approves too :)
Hooray! Thanks for sharing!
Yep, it looks like I’m going to have to make these. After making different versions of those funfetti cupcakes twice already, I think the cookies can’t be far away. And that icing! Swoon.
So stoked to make these tonight. I’m already imagining a variation with apple butter, for when this year’s pumpkin obsession wears off :)
I will make these soon! Too many inticing words not too! (One bowl, simple, one hour start to finish, and pumpkin!!)
ha! Sorry to tempt! Let me know how it goes if you do!
I may need a half dozen ASAP!
Hello!
I just made these and they’re great! I actually used white whole wheat & pastry flour.
I don’t want to make all if the cookies right now though, can I freeze the batter?
Thanks!
Lovely!! I haven’t tried freezing the batter, but I would assume if you froze the little discs it would work fine!
can you make these gluten free?
I used a gf all purpose flour (TJ’s) and they came out well. They spread out more than expected, but still had a good texture.
Love your site, cannot take my eyes off it lately, and just made these. I ran out of flour, so used half whole wheat flour, also no pumpkin spice, so I made my own sans mace and allspice, ok that was dumb- will attempt to be more prepared next time! but these turned out great Dana, thank you for your inspiration.
Made these tonight. Not usually a fan of Pumpkin flavored treats, but my husband is. Gotta say though, they were delicious. Let my almost two year old lick the beaters because it would be bedtime for her when they were ready to eat. She thoroughly enjoyed her portion :)
Only used 2 cups of sugar in the frosting. Made a nice consistency and perfectly sweet. Also, used more pumpkin purée, because we were sans pumpkin butter. They flavor was great, we will just keep them in the fridge to avoid spoiling.
Thanks!
Hi Dana,
Is the dough okay to refrigerate/freeze for a few days? I’m hoping to prep a batch to make on Friday!
Cheers,
Molly
I think it would, but I haven’t tried it! Of course, if you do I’d recommend letting it come back down to room temp before trying to work with it. Let me know how it goes!
I made these cookies for a family gathering this weekend, and they were a huge hit. They were absolutely delicious! I have made many different types of pumpkin cookies over the years, but these were my favorite by far! Thanks for the great recipe!
PS: I featured these cookies on my blog today
Would love to make these but am wondering — can I roll them out and cut with a cookie cutter? How should I do this?
Just made these tonight with my sister to get into the Halloween spirit and they were sooooo delicious!
They’re everything that a sugar cookie should be (cruchy corners and soft inside) and super fitting with the “all pumpkin everythaaaang” theme in the fall.
For our frosting, we added a little pumpkin puree to the mixture and it was awesome.
Nomnom :) thank you for the recipe!!
These are absolutely delicious – it’s as if a spice cookie and a pumpkin whoopie pie had a love child. My 6 and 8yo love them too and proclaimed that when I take them to a neighborhood gathering this evening, they’re going to get them all first! Luckily, there is extra icing so I will be making another batch for us tomorrow. These took me back to pumpkin cookies my mom made when I was little (the recipe has long since been lost) but much, much better.
One small note on the frosting recipe: It says to add the vanilla but there is no amount specified. So, I added 1/2 tsp. Not sure if that was what you intended but the icing was, as my son said, “the best icing I’ve ever tasted.” Thanks for another great recipe and lovely site! I look forward to every email! :-)
Thanks! And thank you for the vanilla note. Amending that now.
Not good. The flavor didn’t even do it for me. I’m considered the “cookie lady” so I know my way around the kitchen but these failed worse than any cookie ever has. Sorry
Can I substitute some other plant-based fat in place of the vegan butter? Do you think substituting melted coconut oil would work?
It may, but I’m not sure! If you give it a try, let me know how it goes!
Question for you.
As mentioned above, I made there and they were a HUGE hit. Since my post last week, I have made 3 batches to share at my daughters 2nd birthday party.
I’m wondering if you have experimented with using cookie cutters? Or is the dough too sticky for that? I saw the same question asked above, but did not see a response.
I needed to flatten them more, but these are delicious! I used this spiced buttercream icing instead: http://ohsheglows.com/2010/10/02/pumpkin-gingerbread-with-spiced-buttercream/
I have made these about 5 times in the last two weeks. This is my favorite recipe I’ve made so far, with the pb&j pie close second. They are absolutely amazing! Even my family, who are the furthest thing from ever being vegan, devoured them. They couldn’t even tell. Such a big hit.
I can’t wait to try out the vegan shephard’s pie and cinnamon rolls tonight, and I’m sure they’re going to be delicious.
PS, I have been following your blog for a little over two years and every single recipe I have tried has been a hit! (breakfast potatoes, mint brownie cashew ice cream, one pot vegan pasta, best damn mashed potatoes, no bake pb&j pie!) Please don’t ever stop!
WOW these were off the scale DELICIOUS! I blew it on mixing the items separately but that didn’t seem to matter. They were so light and fluffy. I think I’ll be leaving them in a tad bit longer because I love that crunchy edge of a cookie.
I shared with friends and got a 100% WOW THANKS back too.
I used GF OAT FLOUR for the gluten-free attempt.
Thsnkd@
I’m trying to make something quick tomorrow before work, to bring to my co-workers, so I have a couple of questions.
1) I’m a little confused about the instructions for whole wheat flour. I’ve never used it before in my baking.
2) I would love to make the frosting, but I don’t have enough pumpkin purée to make the pumpkin butter. Are there any alternative frosting recipes for this recipe, or if I could just use pumpkin purée instead of the butter.
Thanks!
Made these yesterday and were awesome. I did half butter and half vegan shortening I know strange but it’s all I had and they were great. I formed 2 disks and wrapped them in seran wrap. I refrigerated an hour and then put in freezer to firm up more and then roll out 3/4 of the dough and did cookie cutter trees and then did the remaining as you said and both are great . I like traditional sugar cookie no icing and these were so nice being pumpkin and not overpowering. I did homemade royal icing on my trees.
Thank you another great recipe
Emily
This looks great but I dont understand step 3. Is it saying I should add all dry ingredients to a sifter, then stir, then sift over the wet ingredients? OR am I sifting dry ingredients together, then stirring, then adding to wet ingredients?
I saw these cookies and I kid you not, I went in the kitchen and roasted my pie pumpkin for homemade puree, then I baked the seeds and made these FANTASTIC cookies!!! I’m in love :)
I made a test batch and was so impressed by how simple and how delicious this is that I baked a bigger batch the next day. I quadrupled the recipe (2 cups of vegan butter, 6 cups of flour, etc). I forgot to add almond milk; placed the dough in 2 big pastry bags with star tip before chilling. I piped the dough onto the parchment paper creating lovely 1 1/2 inch rosettes. This yielded 220 cookies which were devoured quickly by 20 appreciative adults and kids! They couldn’t believe the cookies were vegan! (Btw, my cookies turned out crispy which I so much.)
(p.s. I have included this recipe in my “Prized Recipes” notebook. Thanks very much for this! More power to you!)
I just made these as I had some leftover pumpkin puree that I had to use it. All I can say is, wow! These are soooo good! Perfect for Fall weather time, and gets one in the mood for Halloween. I will definitely be making these again at Halloween, maybe with cookie cutters and some decorations. I did not frost mine, as they were perfect as is, and I wanted to keep them simple (plus, why mess with perfection!). Can’t wait to see how they are tomorrow, as I have discovered that many vegan baked goods (esp cookies and cupcakes) taste even better the next day or two. Thanks, once again, for another superb recipe! You are now my go-to person for vegan recipes, as they almost always come out perfect and delicious! :-)
I just made these and they are sooooooo good!!!!!! Thank you!!!! I give these a perfect 10!
Yay! thanks for sharing!
Okay Dana, listen:
#1 – These cookies are AMAZING. Seeing as how I’m a “basic bitch” of a vegan and my blood is currently made of pumpkin spice, these cookies were perfect.
#2 – I didn’t have the ingredients for the frosting, so since I’m too lazy to go to the grocery store, I made your pumpkin cashew frosting instead. Still awesome.
#3 – I’ve decided that you are #lifegoals.
#4 – Your last name is almost the same as my maiden name (Shults), so I’ve legally declared that we’re related and I expected to be invited to your holiday dinners.
K thanks bai!
I made these last night and they are amazing! I’ve been passing them out for everyone I know to try and they all love them! This is definitely a keeper. Thanks for the awesome recipes, everything of yours that I’ve tried has turned out fantastic :)
I LOVE these cookies. I made them this morning and they turned out fantastic! They are perfect for fall and are very pumpkiny, which I love. Even my dad (who’s anything BUT vegan) loved them. Will definitely make them again.
I really loved these cookies! I do have a question though – they taste more like gingersnaps than pumpkin cookies – has anyone else experienced this? I am a VERY inexperienced baker, so I am not sure what adjustments would be appropriate? (It’s also quite possible that its me, and not the recipe turn out that way) In either case, what do you think? More pumpkin filling, or just less spice? And if more pumpkin, should I use more flour to keep the consistency?
Any help would be appreciated! I am hoping to make my second batch this week! Thanks!!!!
Perhaps try let spices next time. That’s probably what did it!
Can I make these without vegan ingredients? I was curious because it may effect the cookie itself, but I’m unsure. These look delicious though!
Yes, I think so! Let me know if you give it a try ;D
I just made these for Canadian Thanksgiving and they turned out perfectly! Thanks for the recipe.
I subbed an all-purpose gluten-free flour blend for the flour, which worked well, and they’re still nice and soft.
Yay! Thanks for sharing!!
Thank you so much for this recipe. These might be the most amazing cookies I’ve ever tasted. The frosting is perfect!
Wonderful! Thanks for sharing, Kristi!
Posting again because I meant to rate it also. Five stars for sure!!
Wow… These turned out amazing for Thanksgiving. Also followed your mashed potato recipe and oh my word. Thank you!
Wonderful! So glad you enjoyed them, Caroline!
I made these cookies this morning to take to a pumpkin carving party this evening and they were a huge, gigantic, enormous hit. I even had adults hoarding the last of them from the kids! My husband managed to swipe one and shared it with me or I’d have no idea how awesome they tasted. Really good cookie. The texture was perfect and the frosting totally rocked it. Thank you.
I would love to make these for Halloween, but they need to be gluten free. Do you think that if I substitute the flour for gluten free flour, will it make a difference?
I’m so confused with the first step. It states: “Add softened butter to a large mixing bowl and cream with a mixer for 1 minute.” But in the ingredient list there is no mention of cream. What kind of cream do I mix with the butter?
Oh, cream is using the mixer to blend it into a cream! Sorry to confuse.
These were absolutely amazing. I was almost wishing there was more pumpkin, but I was also looking for a sugar cookie recipe. We never got to make the frosting, but I am sure that would bump up the delicous pumpkin flavor. My boys and I were too excited to wait to make the frosting and they tasted great with out it. Next time we will try to wait and make it.
Do you think substituting applesauce for the vegan butter would negatively impact the final product?
Yes, I wouldn’t recommend it.
I was very excited for these cookies, but was disappointed in the results. My cookies came out extremely thin and crumbly. Not one of the cookies survived without breaking or crumbling. The only recipe substitution I made was using turbinado sugar for all of the sugar. Any thoughts on what happened with my batch?
Turbinado is much grainier and doesn’t act the same in these cookies as cane. That’s probably what went wrong!
I’ve made these twice now and both times they were blooming marvellous. I used GF flour (Doves Farm for UK people) so they were a little crumblier, but still utterly delicious. The first time I made them I iced them all and the added moistness made them disintegrate a bit over the few days before they were all gone. So the second time I made a pot of the icing (sorry – frosting!) and kept in the fridge so we could add as we ate. Big thumbs up!!
Veganism doesn’t include sugar – brown sugar or organic cane sugar.
Sub coconut sugar if you’re concerned.
Actually raw cane sugar is vegan ?
My new favorite cookie! Fun to make on a date night, and we ended up with some amazingly yummy cookies! Thank you!
These. Are. Amazing! I made them for one of my guy friends for his birthday. I bought a big cookie jar and put cute October themed labels on it before I put the cookies in. However, my dad sneakily ate a couple cookies without my notice. Even so, he said those were the best cookies I have made so far! He would have been surprised if I told him they were vegan! My guy friend also said they were extremely delicious along with his sister. I will definitely make these again!
Hi – the instructions say “Dip a glass into cane sugar and then gently smash the cookie ball down into a disc (see photo).” — I don’t see a pic of this – can you point me toward it or email it to me? thanks!
Just as it says, dip the bottom of a class in cane sugar, then use it to smash down the cookie into a flat disc.
My 16 year old daughter has been vegan since she was twelve years old. I made these yummy cookies and she said these were the best cookies she has ever had! These were the only request she had for Thanksgiving! The pumpkin butter we love on toast, bagels, and sliced apples!
So I didn’t realize the pumpkin butter recipe was from oh she glows and I made yours instead…. that will work fine, right?
These were one of your first recipes for me to try, browsing one night for a solution to a craving. I used real butter and left out the pumpkin in the frosting and they were so good and soft.
These are delicious! I added extra pumpkin and added flax when I made them. They are really pumpkiny which is great because pumpkin is so yummy and good for you. And my house smells amazing because of them. Thanks for the great recipe!
Hey :) is it normal that the batter is very doughy more like cake dough? Can i save it with more flour?
I make these all the time and they are my favourite cookie! I want to make a batch of the dough (I have some pumpkin puree leftover that I do not want to waste), and I was wondering if the raw dough can be frozen? If so, how long will it keep in the freezer? Many thanks! :-)
I am a huuge pumpkin spice fan, so I was looking for the perfect recipe, and I definitely found it! Your recipes never ever disappoint :) I wish I could rate this more than 5 stars!
These were like autumn in cookie form. I made a batch and it was gone in like, 3 hours. (a.k.a my fam approves)
I didn’t have any pumpkin butter for the icing, but it turned out very tasty without it :)
Thank you so so much for this recipe!
I made these for a vegan friend and of course I had to try some and they turned out super yummy! I did omit the almond milk as I had none and the dough was soft already. Left them in the fridge overnight and popped them in the oven the next morning. They turned out soft, a little cakey, and perfect.
Everything turned out perfect! It is pretty sweet.. I had two in a sitting. Frosted decadence! That’s not store bought ;)
Also, thank you for the spot on measurements, icing to cookie, and cookie dough, I love when recipe works out that way!
Just made these! They smell delicious and taste even better! We’re sending them with our daughter to a Halloween function tomorrow (but I will admit – we’re keeping a few for ourselves ;P )
LOVE your recipes Dana – every single one I’ve tried has been a smashing success!
I made these for the first time yesterday and brought them to a family get together. Every single person raved over them. They are simply delicious! I did use the optional pumpkin butter (store bought) and vanilla in the frosting and it was seriously some of the best frosting I’ve had. I can’t wait to make another batch to bring to the office. Thanks for the recipe. It’s a definite keeper!
Made these yesterday… hands down the BEST sugar cookies I’ve ever tasted. You know how usually the dough tastes better than the actual cookie? Well, this cookie tastes just as good as the dough! I was skeptical making it without eggs (a first, for me) but I am so happy with how they turned out! Next time I need to make cookies, I’m heading straight to this website!
Nice! Thanks Sam! xoxo
I am excited to try these cookies out. I will let you know how they turn out. I use a lot of your recipes, so thank you.
My family and I loved these! They were so good!
Hi Dana!
Will using gluten-free flour mess with the recipe?
Thanks,
Felicia (:
Yes, but I have a V/GF recipe coming soon!
Oh, wonderful! Thanks for the response! ?
Instead of 1/4 C. pumpkin or apple sauce, I enjoy making these cookies using two flax eggs with some strong green tea as the liquid.
This recipe is fantastic! I’m not vegan normally but some of my friends are. They turned out amazing. 5 stars
I have been vegan for over 1.5 years and this was my first time really experimenting with vegan baking! I usually just buy pre-made items from whole foods because I am afraid to mess up in the kitchen. However, this recipe was so easy to follow, and the batter was amazing… so I knew they were going to turn out great! I brought them to a family gathering and everyone liked them and I didn’t even broadcast that they were vegan. So excited to continue baking in the future! :)
These are fabulous! I used gluten free flour and even used stevia “sugar” instead to save calories! So yummy!! Thank you. Vegan and Gluten Free!!! ????
So good! I used mashed banana because I didn’t have pumpkin and used half applesauce in place of half of the “butter”… so good! And almost healthy, right?! ;)
Argh, I swear I pressed 5 stars!
Hi, this recipe looks great what can I use to replace the all purpose flour?
Hi Bianca! You could use GF flour, or whole wheat flour!
These turned out delicious! I can’t stop eating them. Next time I’ll have to double the recipe. I made the dough at night and baked them in the morning. I am at high altitude and they turned out perfect with no adjustments.
Do you think these could make good whoopie pies?
Hi! That should work!
Already did it and tagged you on Insta ;). Worked like a dream! Thanks always yr my fav!
Hi, could I substitute coconut butter for the earthbalance butter? I don’t have access to vegan butter. Thanks! Love your site! :)
Hi, could I substitute coconut butter for the earthbalance butter? Thanks! Love your site! :)
Hi Lindsey! Yes you can!
Great, thank you!!
I just made these for my son’s Halloween Pumpkin Patch adventure at school tomorrow. They are all about a year old so I decided not to make the frosting to save on the sugar. These are perfect! Not too sweet, soft and easy for little hands and mouths with the perfect amount of pumpkin and spice to remind you of the fall without being overwhelming and in your face. Love these! I will definitely be making these, with the frosting, for the holidays!
These are amazing!! I used pumpkin pie filling instead of puré and didn’t add the pumpkin spice but they were still so good! I found it made less than the recipe states but still absolutely wonderful!! Will be adding to my fall baking list!
I make these for our halloween party and they were outstanding. The flavor was excellent and the icing was creamy goodness. The only thing I did different was to roll the chilled batter on a pastry cloth and use a glass to cut them out. That way I could make sure they were all uniform. Thanks for the recipe. It’s a keeper.
These are absolutely delicious (made them without the frosting). My 10 year old is absolutely addicted, and I have to admit, I am too! My daughter has many food allergies, so I’m always thrilled when I can find something yummy to make her at home. Thanks for the stellar recipe, we will be making these often!
I found mine were chalky to the taste when done. We used gluten free flour though. Any ideas on how to make it less chalky?
For the frosting, can I use the canned pumpkin instead of the pumpkin butter? Same amounts?
Hi Sydney! That should work!
Made these today and oh my goodness, they are amazing! My boyfriend, who is a sugar cookie lover, said these are his favorite cookie I have ever made! I have made probably 20 of your recipes so far and none of them have let me down! Thank you, Dana!
Oh wow! I made these and they turned out amazing it was so easy and fun, the batter was delicious,and the smell made my heart skip! Even if the batter got a little sticky on my hands after freezing and waiting 50 seconds too much , I didn’t mind eating it off!!!!
I made these for Thanksgiving today and they turned out amazing! Thank you so much for the recipe!
Yay! So glad to hear, Brittany!
These are delicious! So glad I made a double batch. My husband said that they’re some of the best cookies he’s ever had. :)
Can I roll them out and shape them?
Yes, I think that will work!
I have made these multiple times and every time they come out ridiculously amazing. I have made some good cookies in my day but these top the list!
Love bringing them to potlucks because the plate is always empty by the end.