My mom used to make her own bread and yogurt from scratch.
I mean, come on. How cool is she?
I remember learning that and thinking my mom was the most awesome hippie mom ever and I wanted to do the same if I was ever a mama.
The bread-making season in our house ended sometime around the arrival of 10-pound me. But can you blame her? She had two babies to look after and who has time to make bread with so much life happening?
Well, the good news is, you do have time to make this bread. I even speculate you could make it with a baby on your hip because it is literally a dump, mix, rise and bake kind of bread! Let’s get to baking!
This recipe is simple in both preparation and ingredients.
Just 9 basic ingredients that are very forgiving. If you don’t have any of the seeds or oats on hand, just omit them! It’s still totally doable.
With a short 20-minute bake time, hands on prep time is only 15 minutes + the rise! Hello, free time.
When I say dump, mix, rise, I mean it.
You literally dump the ingredients in a bowl, mix and let it do its thing in the fridge.
All that’s left to do is knead in the seedy and oat-y things and let it rise once more while the oven preheats.
Twenty minutes later and you have a perfectly delicious, seedy, whole grain loaf on your hands.
This loaf is magnificent; everything you want in a homemade bread. It’s:
Seriously simple
Tender on the inside
Crusty on the outside
Loaded with whole grains
Seedy
Dreamy
& Perfect
This makes the perfect bread for toast, sandwiches, french toast, and everything in between.
I’ve been loving it with smashed avocado and a little vegan parmesan cheese and hemp seeds, or with peanut butter and flax seed. You really can’t go wrong.
More Vegan Bread Recipes
If you give this recipe a try, let us know! Leave a comment, rate it, or take a picture and tag it #minimalistbaker on Instagram! We’d love to see what you come up with. Happy baking!
The Easiest Whole Grain Seeded Bread
Ingredients
- 1 1/2 cups warm water
- 3/4 Tbsp fast-acting yeast (1 packet yields ~3/4 Tbsp or 2 1/4 tsp)
- 2 Tbsp maple syrup, agave, or honey if not vegan
- 1/2 Tbsp salt
- 1 Tbsp flaxseed meal
- 2 cups Bob’s Red Mill Whole-Wheat Pastry Flour
- 1 3/4 cups Bob’s Red Mill Unbleached All-Purpose Flour (plus more for rolling / dusting)
- 2 Tbsp raw or roasted sunflower seeds
- 2 Tbsp rolled oats
Instructions
- Combine warm water (like bath water, or 110 degrees F / 43 C), yeast, maple syrup (or other sweetener), salt, flaxseed meal, and flours in a large mixing bowl and stir. The result will be a sticky, rough dough. If using a stand mixer, beat at medium speed for about a minute. Otherwise just use a spoon to stir until well combined and when it can no longer do the job, knead and turn it in the bowl with your hands. Add flour until the dough is no longer sticking to the sides – about 3 3/4 cups total (amount as original recipe is written // adjust if altering batch size).
- Lift the dough out and lightly grease the bowl with nonstick spray or olive oil. Cover and let rise for 2 hours at room temperature and 2 hours in the fridge. Alternatively, if you only have 2 hours, let rise at room temperature and skip the fridge (though a longer rise is best).
- Use fingers to create a small hole in the dough and pour in sunflower seeds and oats. Transfer dough to a lightly floured work surface and knead about 20 turns or until elastic. Form into a loaf-like shape.
- Place seam-side down in a lightly greased loaf pan or baking sheet and sift a light coating of flour over the top to help keep the dough moist. Loosely cover with plastic wrap and let rest for 45-60 minutes.
- Preheat oven to 425 degrees F (218 C)* toward the end of the dough resting time and place a metal or cast iron pan (NOT glass, Pyrex, or ceramic) on the lowest oven rack. Also have 1 cup of hot water ready.
- When the oven is preheated, slash the bread 2 or 3 times with a knife, making a cut about ½-inch deep.
- Place in oven on middle rack. Then carefully pour hot water into the shallow pan on the rack beneath. Expect it to bubble and steam; then close oven door quickly.
- Bake the bread for 26 to 35 minutes, or until deep golden brown and risen.
- Remove the bread from the oven and let rest in the pan for 5 minutes. Then carefully remove from pan and transfer to a cooling rack to cool. Let it cool completely before slicing for best results (otherwise it can be doughy in the middle).
- Store leftovers in a plastic bag at room temperature for up to a few days. Transfer to freezer for longer term storage.
Video
Notes
*Adapted from my 7 Ingredient Muesli Bread.
*Nutrition information is a rough estimate.
Nutrition (1 of 12 servings)
This post was sponsored by the lovely folks at Bob’s Red Mill. Thanks for supporting the brands that support Minimalist Baker!
Rebekah Adamson says
Can you specify how big of a loaf pan you are using? Just trying to gauge what pan to use
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
9×5 inches!
Tammy says
First attempt at making my own bread. I wanted something simple so I omitted the oats and seeds. I used white whole wheat flour instead of pastry flour. Very pleased with the results and will make again but maybe try to figure out how to cut some of the calories out.
Emily says
This is my new favorite bread! I’ve been using it for sandwiches, toast, or just eating a slice with butter — it’s wonderful! I couldn’t find whole wheat pastry flour at my usual grocery store and didn’t have time to hunt around so I subbed in half regular whole wheat flour and half pastry flour in place of the whole wheat pastry flour. I’ve made it twice this way and has turned out great each time! I also skipped the oats (my son is allergic) and used sesame seeds instead, and they are wonderful in this bread. Thanks for such a great recipe!
Kathryn says
I made this bread with sprouted spelt and whole wheat flours and regular yeast. It’s beautiful!!! I am so thrilled to have found this recipe! I’ve started rising my dough over a bowl of boiling water, and it rises the dough so efficiently! Thank you for the recipe. I love all of your posts! ❤
Christina says
I’m not sure if anyone has commented or asked this before, but can you freeze the dough and then thaw it and bake it at a later date? Would that do anything funky to rise? Thanks!
Dana @ Minimalist Baker says
Hmm, I think that would work? Let me know if you give it a try!
Divi says
I love this bread. I use chopped walnuts instead of sunflower seeds. However, I am confused about the time needed for prep and baking. It says 4 hours and 36 minutes, but two hours out of plus two hours in the refrigerator, 45 minutes resting on the pan plus 26 to 30 minutes in the oven comes to over 5 hours and 15 minutes. Am I misunderstanding the directions?
Thanks!
Dana @ Minimalist Baker says
The time is an estimation for the least amount of rising suggested.
Georgina Stewart says
First time making bread and it turned out so well! Thanks for such a great recipe, I will definitely be back again!
Rck says
Hey Dana! This recipe looks amazing and easy; my two favorite combos in the kitchen. However, I was wondering if I could use normal whole wheat flour instead of whole wheat pasty flour? I can’t wait to try this out!
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
Hi! Yes! It will be a little more hearty/rustic, but still delicious!
Rck says
Thank you! I’m so sorry for bothering you again, but how about if I used rye flour instead of the whole wheat pastry flour?
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
We haven’t tried it, but sounds delicious! Let us know if you try it!
Kristi says
Just made this bread. Yum! I did make a couple of changes based on what I had on hand. I used more AP flour because I didn’t have the whole wheat pastry flour and I was wary of the denseness of regular WW flour. I did 2 teaspoons of salt and threw it all in my bread maker. So easy and delicious! Thank you Dana! Keep it coming!
Becca says
Fresh out the oven, and already in love! I have been meaning to make bread for MONTHS, but I have been way too nervous! I have prepared myself for it by making lots of pizza dough and rolls, but I finally bit the bullet today and discovered your recipe! I already know and love many of your pancake + muffin recipes (as a non-vegan home), so I knew it was a good bet. Super easy, even for a newbie, and yummy! I mostly loved how few ingredients it had, and all the options to add more texture and variations on sweeteners. Excited to see how it lasts and works for sandwiches/toast.
Janet Luo says
I made this today and I have no experience with bread. I used average whole wheat flour and all purpose and all the above measurements. I found a needed a little more flour because it was a little too sticky but you do want it a little sticky anyway. I was petrified when pouring the water into the tray below it but succeeded in the end and I lowered the temperature to about 200C as it browned too fast and put foil over the top and cooked for about 20 minutes extra, it was perfect and cooked inside. I was scared it was going to be raw and uncooked. I would recommend putting in more than the listed amount of seeds to get a better distribution. It worked perfectly, love this and will definitely make again.
Jasmine Brown says
I just finished making this bread. It has very much lived up to my expectations! Great flavor, even without milk, butter, and eggs. My daughter has a dairy and egg allergy but she loves bread. I’m so happy to have found a recipe that is so good! I have had a lot of experience making bread and needed to speed up the recipe because I only had 3-4 hours. I followed the recipe but not the rising times (instead letting it rise in a warm oven till doubled for first rise and on the counter as directed for the second). This was so delishious. Thank you so much for this great recipe. I can only imagine that with the extra rise time, the loaf would be more flavorful and chewy. Thanks again!
Jasmine Brown says
delicious. ha.
Rachel says
This bread is very tasty! However, for me it always turns out fairly dense; it’s not a chewy, crusty bread like the kind my local bakery sells. I don’t necessarily mind the difference, but I’m curious about it. I always use regular whole wheat flour rather than whole wheat pastry flour. Could that be the difference?
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
That could be the issue!
TANYA ROY says
What can I use instead of pastry flour? Can I use almond meal after having made almond milk?
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
Hi Tanya! We haven’t tried using almond meal for this one, so I cannot strongly recommend that. How about spelt or whole wheat?
Nikki says
I’ve been making this bread for the past few weeks and it’s amazing. It’s hearty, tasty, doughy, crusty…we can’t get enough at my house. We use it for toast, as a side, to build egg breakfasts on top of…always good. It’s also so easy to make and cost effective. Thank you for this recipe!!
cookingirl says
Any chance you have a good sub for white flour? I don’t use any refined flours in my baking but would really like to try this recipe!
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
Hi! You can probably use bread flour instead of all purpose but I haven’t tried that so can’t comment! If you give it a try, report back on how it goes!
Kelsey says
I did white bread flour + regular whole wheat and it worked great! Not too dense but still hearty, and has a good flavor.
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
Yay! Thanks for sharing! xo
Ashley says
I made this once with White Whole Wheat Flour as I could not find the pastry flour. It turned out great. Am curious though, what if I didn’t use the AP flour and used all White Whole Wheat Flour instead?
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
Hi Ashley, it would likely end up more dense. But let us know if you try it!
Jessica says
How important are the sunflower seeds in this recipe? I think I have everything else and I’ve been really wanting to try making my own bread lately.
My ultimate goal is to someday learn how to make my own sourdough bread…I looked up a recipe the other day though and for only having 1 ingredient it was super long and complicated! lol
Jessica says
Nevermind…I just found another comment asking the same question!
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
Leave em out! Enjoy!
Jessica says
Did all your steps and it turned out perfectly. Getting ready to make more!
Nancy says
I’ve made this three times in the last few weeks and I have loved it every time! The seeds and oatmeal integrated into it are just the right touch to make it interesting and healthy.
Kim Penski says
Love your recipes! This vegan recipe can the unbleached white flour be replaced with any other whole grain flour and be successful?
Thanks,
Kim
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
Hi Kim, it will likely end up more dense, but it is possible to sub whole wheat or spelt flour.
Natasha Mazni says
Hi, can I omit the flax seed? It’s quite expensive here, or is there a replacement for it ? Thanks.
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
Nope! Leave it out.
Ros Resnick says
Brilliant best bread i have made. Now going to try adding different nuts and dates to see how it is. Thanks
Tasha Zinck says
Hi, I just tried your recipe, it turned out perfect, crusty outside, soft inside, tastes amazing…This will definitely be my go to bread recipe from now on!
Alison says
Hi this bread looks wonderful. I have all the ingredients to make, but my problem is I don’t have the time to make, rise and bake it in one evening. Can I make the dough and freeze? At what point can I do That? After the 4 hours, or after the last 45-60 min of sitting before it goes in the oven? If I wanted to make the dough, can I let it rise then leave it in the fridge til the next evening? I am a baking novice.
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
Hi! While I would not recommend freezing the dough, you can refrigerate it and bake it the next day! Just let it get to room temperature before baking! Good luck!
Kat says
So I made this in my bread machine with the dough cycle. I used all the Ingreidents except the sunflower seeds and oats.
I used my oven to the rest, and the recipe was great.
Anthony Andrews says
Love it! Though I used Chia and poppy seeds instead of Sunflower seeds ( not really for taste, but I just feel like sunflower seeds need to be taken down a peg… Walkin’ ’round like they own the joint). Anywho, I’m making this as a valentine’s day present for my boss. It’s THAT good…. And I’m that cheap. I’ll be baking more from your site, trust and believe.
Linda Finch says
Love this recipe. I added a cup of muesli cereal to it….pulled back a bit on the whole wheat flour. Added sunflower seeds too. Amazing toasted. Let it rise in refrig until I was an ready to deal with it…..very hearty and delicious. Make two lia es…give away one so as not to eat it all! I use honey and do not add salt.
Amrita says
Hi. Can the dough be left for 4 hours at room temperature? Or is the refrigeration an important step?
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
Hi! I haven’t tried it but that should work! Report back on how it goes! :D
valerie scovill says
That’s what I did. I left it out for 4 hours to rise and it turned out just fine.
valerie scovill says
Whoops, meant to give it 5 stars.
Yorleny says
Valerie, when you left it out for 4 hours…did you put straight in the oven after that? Or is the kneading after letting it rise and resting again a MUST? Thanks!
judy says
Oh my GOODNESS! Just made it…we didn’t wait for it to completely cool! AWESOME! Thank you so much for the recipe! Will always be making this!
Kathy H says
I attempted this recipe yesterday and it was a fail :-( I accidentally used KA Bread Flour instead of AP flour, and after kneading the dough in my KA, the dough was still extremely wet and did not leave side of bowl until I added a fair amount of additional flour. I have made Amish bread with great success, but wanted to try something healthier. The final bread after baking had a large doughy hole in the center and the crust did not darken up. Any idea what I did wrong? It took all day to make.
Cecily Dent says
No need to respond. Your timing didn’t quite add up, 2 x 2hour rise, then a 45-60 minute rise,…. that said I made this and like it a lot. It ‘spread’ a bit because I didn’t use a tin. I’ll definitely make again and use a tin this time for a ‘higher’ loaf.
LInda says
Hi, I just wanted to add that I made this in the bread machine (I have a Zojirushi) and it turned out wonderfully well. I did pan toast the sunflower seeds and the oats before adding them, but didn’t wait for the mix in cycle – I just dumped everything in according the instructions for my bread machine. I did use the ‘quick wheat’ setting but honestly, this can probably use the basic cycle or maybe dark. It’s rustic but SO light – make wonderful toast, which I used for avocado toast, and I can imagine this with lots of Irish butter and strawberry jam. This is a keeper.
Beverly Hayes says
I really want to try this recipe! A few questions–1.Does it double (or triple!) well? 2. If I am baking two or three at the same time, do I need to increase the baking time and also the amount of water poured in the bottom pan? We are a family of seven and one loaf would not be enough! And last but not least, 3. Why are the oats and seeds added after the two hour resting period in the fridge? What happens if I add the seeds while I’m mixing everything in the beginning? Thanks for your recipe! Can’t wait to try it and post a review on my own blog. Thanks!
Dana @ Minimalist Baker says
Hi Beverly!
1 – I think so! I haven’t tried it that way but there’s no reason it wouldn’t. Just make sure you give the dough proper room when baking (in the oven and the size of the pans.
2 – I would increase the baking time, yes. The more loaves in the oven the longer it will take. Just keep an eye on it. No need to increase the water.
3 – You can definitely add the oats and seeds whenever you’d like! Good luck!
Keith Janssen-Kragness says
WOW, this was so easy, and better than store bought. Will be making this A LOT ! 5 STARS !
Alex Brown says
I used this recipe to make bread for the very first time and it turned out amazing! I made the bread last night and it’s already gone, so thank you for posting this.
Jen R says
Is it possible to mix the ingredients and keep the dough in the refrigerator overnight to bake the following day? I bought all the ingredients, and this will be my first time attempting to bake bread. Thanks!
Beverly Hayes says
I don’t think that would hurt it at all. I leave bread dough in the fridge all the time to stop the rising process. I think this step is needed to allow all the flavors to come together. I would leave it in the fridge until the next morning and bake it then. Let me know how it turns out!
Jen R says
Thanks for the feedback. I will certaintly try this as I made the recipe last Saturday and felt like it tied up most of my Saturday. However, my first attempt at baking bread using this recipe was a success! (I added three tablespoons of chia seeds.)
Nancy says
My dough rose very well during the first rise and again during second rise in loaf pan. As soon as I picked it up to put in oven it fell. What did I do wrong?
Nancy Robinson
Beverly Hayes says
When a risen bread dough falls it’s mostly because the rising time was too long. Make sure you don’t let it rise for more than double its starting size. In fact, I don’t usually let my bread completely double because I know it will rise more when it goes in the oven. So watch it carefully while rising, and when it gets to “almost” double in size, have your oven ready (preheated and everything) when you put it in to bake. Also, when shaping your bread, push out ALL the bubbles and shape it pretty tight. If you don’t, then your “doubling” measurement will be off. I hope this helps!
Liz says
Looks wonderful Making it tonight for dinner. So easy! It is proofing now. Thank you so much for sharing!
Lindsay says
Absolutely loved this bread!! I’ve been making homemade white and wheat bread for years and this is my favorite of them all. I followed the measurements in the recipe exactly, using honey for the sweetener. For the whole wheat flour, I ground the wheat berries in my wheat grinder on the finest setting (1.5 cups wheat berries equals 2 cups flour). I let it rise 2 hours on the counter, 2 in the fridge, used the dough hook on my mixer to stir in the seeds, then let it rise another 45 minutes on the counter. Baked for 30 minutes in a bread pan, and it came out absolutely perfect!! I loved eating every bite of it. If I had a complaint, it would be that it is definitely a FULL day from starting the process to being completely cooled, but it was worth it for the final outcome. Thanks for the recipe, I loved it!
Monica says
Thank you so much for this! I was hoping someone had tried it! Question – did you grind your own wheat for both of the types of flours listed? So 3 3/4 cups (plus some for dusting)?
Also, what type of wheat berries do you use?
Lindsay says
I ground hard white wheat berries for the wheat flour. I used 1.5 cups of wheat berries which equaled 2 cups of wheat flour once ground. Then for the white flour I used 1.75 cups of store-bought bread flour (Turkey Flour from Costco.) I’ve made this bread tons of times and every time it’s absolutely delicious!! Good luck, let me know if you have any more questions!
Monica says
Oh, bummer – was hoping you had used all fresh ground flour. Guess I’ll just have to try it! :) I don’t like to use any flour from the store… loses too many nutrients…
Juli says
Hi Dana!
I was wondering if it’s possible to switch up the flours… I mean instead of whole wheat pasty flour use all purpose pastry flour and instead of AP flour use WW flour. Can’t seem to find whole wheat pastry flour where I live.
Thanks!
Beverly Hayes says
In my experience, your bread will still turn out fine if you switch the flours. It will probably taste less wheaty, but that’s basically it. I’ve been baking whole wheat bread for over 15 years, and sometimes when I ran out of wheat flour I would add white flour to finish it off. It always turned out great! So go ahead and experiment! It’s very difficult to hurt bread dough. Promise!
Jasmine says
I have made this recipe twice now.
The first time I ended up with a very dense, small, somewhat misshapen loaf.
The second time I took more care to keep the bread in a warm place during the first and third rises, and shaped it more carefully…and I waited a full hour before cutting into it.
It turned out amazing! Crispy crust, cohesive crumb insides, delicious nutty flavor.
Mels says
This is s great recipe and I’ve made it many times. One problem I have is that it always looks ugly. The slashing (and I make sure it’s just s half inch deep) makes it look deformed on top. What would be the hazard in now slashing it at all? Also, 2 side notes: my Bobs Red Mill WW pastry flour bag says a cup would be 120 grams, which is standard for flour weight and differs from what you list. Secondly, you list “flax seed ” as an ingredient and until now I’ve been using whole flax seed in this bread. I just happened to see one of your comments that said you intended the recipe to use ground flax seed. Every other recipe will specify “ground,” if not the assumption would be that you are using whole. Kind of like if you want a recipe to use chopped walnuts, you wouldn’t just call for “walnuts.”
Beverly Hayes says
As far as the slashing goes, I don’t slash my bread because I like the look of a smooth loaf. It is mostly done to allow the dough to rise freely while baking, but if you choose not to slice it, it should not alter the final outcome. At least that has been my experience with bread baking. Hope this helps!
Yasi says
Just made this, my first time making bread. I used 3.5 cups of the flour combo and my dough was very dry, not coming together. Had to triage with more water then more flour. It seems to be rising fine now, we shall see…
Always thankful for your recipes though. Your banana muffins have become a staple in our kitchen.
Beverly Hayes says
It is very tricky sometimes to avoid adding too much flour when making bread by hand. Make sure you measure correctly (use a knife to level off your cup measurements and don’t pack the measuring cup). Also, if you have a bread mixer, use it to mix your ingredients. You can add the wet ingredients first and then add the flour one cup at a time until the sides of the bowl come clean. That’s an easy way to avoid ending up with a dry dough that breaks apart. Hope this helps!
Ashley Ellis says
This is my very first time making bread and I love it! But, I have a couple questions that come with my inexperience. First off, I bought regular whole wheat flour because I had trouble finding the pastry flour (on amazon and in store!) in hindsight, after reading more about it, I guess that can make kind of a big difference. Next, I live in Colorado and at 8000ft! Which can also make a huge difference! The time and temperature seem to be okay but the bread seems to be kind of “cracking” a lot and hard to keep well shaped and together. Please advise, more water? Pastry flour next time…Thanks :)
Katie says
Wow! This bread came out PERFECT. Bakery quality perfect. I’m not much of a baker and found the recipe simple and forgiving. Here are the minor modifications I made: regular active yeast, regular whole wheat flour instead of pastry, whole chia seeds instead of flax, 1 hour rise in a warm spot and 2 hours in the fridge, 40 minutes at 425.
I will be making this every week! Thank you!!!
Sheryl says
Can I make this with out the flax and sunflower seeds?
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
Yes!
Christine says
How would you change rising instructions for regular yeast. I have lots of that so would like to use it.
Looks easy and wonderful!!
Beverly Hayes says
Regular yeast has to be proofed before being added to the other flour. Take your yeast and add it to the warm water with the sweetener. Let it sit for about 30 minutes or until you see your yeast being activated (bubbles and foam). At that point, you can add everything else and continue with the recipe. Let me know how it goes!
Darla Lord says
I have made this several times (it always comes out great, so thank you for the recipe). I must not shop the better stores, because I haven’t been able to locate whole wheat pastry flour, so I just used regular whole wheat flour by Gold Medal and Pillsbury white. The first time, I had never used quick rising yeast and knew nothing of refrigerator rising, and I had regular yeast on hand so went that route. It is still warm and humid here in SE Texas, so it came up pretty well in a couple of hours sitting in my gas oven with the pilot light on, then I let it go another hour on the counter. I used steel cut oats instead of regular oats. Other than that, I followed the recipe and my husband and I both loved it. I couldn’t find my bread pan, so used parchment paper on a cookie sheet and made a round loaf. I made it again a couple of days later and tried the quick rise yeast and the fridge rising. It still didn’t take the full 4 hours to get big. Last night, I found my loaf pan and made it again, this time substituting pumpkin seed for the oats and it is every bit as good. It is good to be making bread again. I had not done it for many years and the last time I made whole wheat bread it was a total fail, as one of your other commenters wrote, it came out like a brick. But this recipe works for me, even though I still don’t like to let it rise in the fridge, it’s nice to have the option. I’m going to try it with other kinds of seeds too, though I probably put in too many for most people. I may even try a few nuts. I don’t suppose it would hurt anything. Thanks again for the wonderful bread recipe and for getting me back into bread making. It’s very therapeutic.
Sarianna says
I make this all of the time now and it is so amazing. My whole family is obsessed. Thanks for the recipe.
Ridhi says
Hii. This looks too good. I am going to try this.
I have a question – how does adding water on the dish where the loaf pan is help?
I don’t have a loaf pan. Can I just put on the bake tray directly n bake? Thanks
Dana @ Minimalist Baker says
That’s worth a shot! The water helps add moisture to the bread. But if you skip it let me know how it goes!
Ridhi says
Yup !! Will let you know.. One more query please..
I understand that dough rises in high temperature.. How will it rise in the ref?
Thanks for keeping patience in answering my queries.
Dana @ Minimalist Baker says
It will rise but far slower. Good luck!
Azza says
Hello Dana
Can I subtitle recipes for Arabic with your permission
Thanks a lot ?
Ken says
I often retard sourdoughs to slow yeast growth while encouraging lacto-bacterial activity to enhance sourness. What is the reason for retarding yeast breads that have no lacto-bacteria?
Sam says
This Loaf is not as easy as it is made to sound and the time listed is incorrect since it states right in the directions that you need more time then it first leads you to believe.
I made this loaf and it took close to 7 HOURS!!! 20mins to mix ingredients, 4 hours to rise (in and out of the fridge), 15-20mins to mix again, 1hr to rise again, and then 40mins in the oven plus cooling.
ALL THAT TIME SPENT AND I ONLY GOT ONE SMALL LOAF OF BREAD, following a different receipe I could have made dozens of loafs in that time!!!!!
Also, in the beginning it says to add the “flours” and then later has you adding MORE flour that wasn’t even listed in the original ingredients list. HOW MUCH FLOUR IS ACTUALLY NEEDED FOR THIS RECEIPE??
I thought it would be easy (like it says), instead I was up half the night finishing what I started in the early evening. FAIL!
Dana @ Minimalist Baker says
So strange! So many people have had success with this recipe. The flour amounts vary depending on what kind of flour you use and the climate and the general consistency of the dough. That’s why I leave a range with instructions on how to adjust.
Katelyn says
When I first read this recipe I was confused the way it was written, too. It sounds like you are adding 3 cups and then 3 cups again. It is just the first 3 and 3/4 cups. If you read the recipe once through you will see that this is a recipe you make when you are hanging around the house for the day. I think it was WELL WELL worth it and so simple!! This will be a regular in our house. As I only need one loaf of bread a week. : ) Could you do all whole wheat pastry flour or sub whole wheat flour for the all purpose?
Katelyn says
Also, my dough didn’t rise any in the fridge, could I just skip this step or is the cool temperature needed?
a says
totally – I started at 6 pm and it’s nearly midnight and I’ve still got 10 minutes left in the oven. insane. I hope it is worth it in the end but this much sitting time is crazy!
Paris says
Very good turnout. Thanks!!
Tami says
I just made the bread and it looks and smells delicious! How do you store it to keep it crusty? Do you freeze it right away if you’re not going to eat it immediately and if so, in what? Great recipe, thank you! Looking forward to making it again and again. :)
Dana @ Minimalist Baker says
Hi Tami! I store it at room temp loosely covered. But yes, the freezer also keeps it crusty! Just slice before freezing.
Tami says
Thank you Dana! The bread is delicious. I sliced the bread before putting into the freezer but next time I will have to let it cool all the way. I couldn’t wait to try it. Looking forward to trying more of your recipes. :)
Jaclyn says
Can I just use wholemeal bread flour?
Dana @ Minimalist Baker says
It’s worth a shot!
Carla says
Hi, what size bread pan did you use for this recipe? I have e a 1lb (small) and a 2lb tin.
Thanks
Dana @ Minimalist Baker says
Hi there! Mine was a standard 9×5 inch. Good luck!
Mai says
It’s my first time to make any kind of bread and I’m glad I found this recipe! It came out great!
Clo says
It. Is. Everything. Thanks for the recipe!!
Grace says
I was really excited to try this recipe! I went out and bought the sunflower seeds and oats and was ready to roll. I followed the faster instructions, by putting the dough in the fridge for two hours. I then put the seeds in the hole and turned for 20 times and then let it rise and preheated the oven. I poured in the hot water and let it cook for 30 minutes, after that it was still doughy on the inside. I further put it in for another 10 minutes and the sides were still not completely cooked. After five minutes I cut into it and all the seeds fell out from the inside and there was a hollow space where the seeds fell onto my kitchen counter. The bread tasted sooo bad, it was literally like liking the back of a stamp over and over again. I was intrigued at the many steps included but in the end it didn’t turn out for me.
Carolyn says
I made this bread yesterday. Instead of nuts I added Rosemary. I used brown sugar instead of honey. Baked it on a cookie sheet with parchment paper and used coconut oil to grease the bowl, the top of the bread and the parchment paper it rested on. It IS incredible. I just ate it toasted with some vegan cream cheese. I am in heaven. I dont know that ill ever buy bread again. I just can never go back. And it was so easy .
Georgia says
Is the two hour rise at room temperature first? Then do you kneed down for the two hour frig rise?
Dana @ Minimalist Baker says
Yes, the first rise is at room temp.
Alison says
This is amazingly easy with ingredients even a poor student can afford! My only let down was, that it tastes very plain. Next time, I’ll definitely throw some dried herbs in it. Thanks for sharing!
anu says
can i use regular white whole wheat flour instead of both the flours??
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
Hi Ann, it may end up more dense, but it should work. Let us know if you try it!
Kay says
Can I substitute regular whole wheat flour if I do not have any whole wheat pastry flour?
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
That should work!
Audra says
Does this rise for 4 hours?? 2 at rm temperature & 2 in the fridge?
It looks delish!
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
Yes! Although you’ll notice in line 2 of the directions, you could “Alternatively, go straight for the fridge for two hours to save time, though a longer rise is best.”
Lisa says
Nice recipe! Super easy. I actually reduced the white flour to 3/4 cup and added an extra cup of the whole wheat pastry flour. Further, I left out the seeds (not everyone in my home is s a fan of seeds in bread) and freely shaped the loaf instead of putting it in to a pan to give it a more artisan appearance. It came out really nice! We enjoyed it with homemade, chunky split pea soup and green salad.
April Janzen says
I made this but forgot to add the honey till the bread had been rising for about 15 minutes. My bread did not rise. Is this why? I’m frustrated as this is my second attempt at this bread :(
Christy says
Probably, because the yeast needs the sugar to activate.
Beverly Hayes says
Yes, the sweetener feeds the yeast! That’s one ingredient you don’t want to leave out.
melissa says
I’ve never baked bread EVER….I just pulled this bread from the oven and it is perfect! Very very easy!!
Lorrie says
I printed this recipe out on 9/23/16. I made it the following week, following recipe exactly using the cup measurements. The bread tasted okay but was dense and heavy. I made it again this morning and instead of using measurements by cup I used my gram scale for the flours. There is definitely a discrepancy with the grams (more flour with the gram weight) and cup measurements. It is rising right now and wont be finished until late afternoon, but it will be interesting to see the difference in texture, weight. I think the recipe should give all gram measurement for all ingredients as well as cup measurements.
Yehezkel says
Hello I am on the way of doing this as my first bake recipt, I was able to find whole wheat flour but I am missing the word “pastry” on it, can I use such flour?,
Thanks in advance
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
Pastry flour is slightly different than regular flour, for best results I would use whole wheat pastry flour!
Nicole says
I tried to make this bread tonight, and I must have done something wrong! What I got was a giant, round, burnt-on-top, chewy-on-the-inside ball. I didn’t put the dough in a pan but instead baked it on a cookie sheet. I also forgot to score the dough. But what did I do so wrong to end up with an inflated ball of chewy dough with a burnt top crust?!
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
Those couple of alterations might have been the cause!
Andrew M. says
I must say, I have fallen in love with your recipes! This was the first time I’ve made homemade bread and it turned out absolutely perfect! I am so pleased with the results. I did cut back on the salt, used all-purpose flour instead of pastry and whole wheat, and added plain sugar instead of honey or agave. I am glad that it worked out so nicely for me, considering I was going into this with no prior experience. I have just recently switched to vegan living and was concerned about breads and pastries, but your recipes have made it so much more fulfilling for me as a young cook. Thanks so much. Can’t wait to get a copy if your cookbook!
TF says
Hi, why do most whole wheat bread recipes call for a sweetener like honey or molasses or agave? Is whole wheat flour naturally more bitter? Thank you!
AB says
Because otherwise the bread won’t rise, as yeast relies on sugar to activate!
Sonja says
My new go to bread recipe! I was looking for something seedy and heartier than my normal white bread recipe, but didn’t want it to take too much time. This fit the bill and the result exceeded my expectations! Both my kids love it, too!!! Love how soft it is on the inside and crispy on the outside. Just perfect. I added some raw pumpkin seeds for extra crunch! Yum!
Pam Ndasaka says
Very easy to follow recipe.I also added pumpkin seeds.Delicious bread.
Deb says
It was a total failure for me, as heavy as a brick. I did 2 hours Rising time on the counter and two hours in the refrigerator
Linda Molina says
Same thing happened to me. I question the extra flour amount used “until dough is no longer sticking to the sides. After 2 cups of flour, the dough seemed very dry. It never really rose properly and I followed all other directions.
Josh says
Delicious. Will do again. Proofed the yeast with honey and the honey flavor really came through. I do find any whole wheat flour bread requires a little extra baking time then recipes publish. Also do not be tempted to add more flour when doing the initial mixing and kneading. It’s a sticky dough. I used the scoop and throw on the work surface method. It creates a nice tight structure.
June says
I haven’t made bread from scratch in many years, if ever. My husband had always hated a heavy, seeded bread. Not so with this recipe. We both LOVE it. Eady to make. It’s just call the rising times that makes it an all day project. We live in Fl and I found that putting it, covered, out on the porch is wonderful for rising because of the coolness we like inside. I give it an A+++++
Jesi says
Something to try the next time you make this (just for funsies). Take a portion of the flour and toast it in the oven. Just spread some of the flour on a baking sheet and bake it! I set the oven to 325 degrees and stir the flour every 5-10 minutes. It smells amazing and doesn’t take very long. It’s pretty much done when you think it’s done (depending on how strong you want the taste to be). It adds a bit of a nutty flavor to your baking. You could also do the same in a frying pan if that is easier for you.
Thanks for the recipe! I can’t want to try it out! I’m also very excited to [finally] find a bread recipe that doesn’t make multiple loaves.
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
Thanks for the tip Jesi!
Fiachra says
Hey this looks great but I can’t eat gluten, if I change the WW flour to something else like Hemp/Buckwheat flour will it affect the recipe much?
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
Great question Fiachra! We haven’t tried this recipe with hemp or buckwheat flour but if you do, let us know how it goes!
Matthew says
We LOVE this bread. My fiance and I made it back and spring, and ever since then we’ve baked all the bread we’ve eaten! We made this several times after we found it and it worked like a charm every time. We recently switched to sourdough (it’s just better), but wanted to try this recipe again for nostalgia. It works really well leavened by sourdough while still maintaining everything we love about this recipe. Thanks for the inspiration!
Jasmine says
Thank you so much for this recipe! This bread is soooo good!!! I didn’t expect it to turn out so yummy!!
Marilyn Czech says
This is the easiest bread I have ever made. We love it. I have made 4 loaves so far & it is delicious. A couple of things that I am doing different are… I let the dough rise covered in the fridge for 2 hours & skip the prior 2 hours at room temperature. After that I leave covered in the bowl at room temperature for about 30 minutes. I followed through with the kneading with the oats & sunflower seeds, shaping into a loaf & placing in the bread pan. I let that rise for 45 minutes & for the final 15 minutes for a full 60 minutes I pre-heat the oven to 425 degrees. We use a gas stove so the covered bread pan is put on the stove top near the back vent which emits heat & this helps raise the dough a little bit more. The bread is baked per the recipe but for 30 minutes. I have made 3 loaves by this method, using local honey. Thanks for this recipe. It is the home baked bread we were looking for. Too bad I can’t post some pictures, this bread is truly amazing.
Sofiya says
Thank you a lot for the recipe! It was the first time that I was baking a bread and the result is just awesome!
Katie Cross says
This bread was delicious. Super fast. I did the short rise and because I was still short on time only had it sit 15 minutes before cooking. Still came out fab. A definite keeper.
Cheryl says
I was really disappointed in this bread. I followed the recipe exactly including the 4 hours of rising and must say it was only ok. I will try the basic recipe again, but add additional salt and either brown sugar or molasses. I’m surprised folks rated it so high.
Ruth says
Hi! Can I use all whole wheat pastry flour? And can I omit the flaxseeds bc I don’t have any?
Dana @ Minimalist Baker says
Yes!
Jean says
HI! I was wondering if you could make this ahead and leave to rise on the countertop for longer if you can’t make it to the fridge??? Say….If I can’t make it home from work to put in fridge??
Thanks so much!!
Jean
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
Hi Jean, in that case, we would probably recommend skipping the room temp rise and just doing a longer rise in the refrigerator.
Andrea says
Fantastic recipe…my go-to!
To all the avid bakers out there: let your imagination and creativity flow! Add to it whatever you like, try out different flours etc., etc., etc.
I always add oat germ to the recipe, a wonderful addition.
Also, you can never go wrong with adding dates or raisins, walnuts or pecans. One of my favorite is cutting back on the all purpose flour and adding approx. 2/3 cups of coffee flour…simply devine!
I’ve tried many varieties, none of which were disappointing or failed. Adding herbs or even spinach make for a delicious loaf if you want to add an extra kick to your panini.
Emily Sumner says
What is the difference between instant yeast, active yeast and the “fast acting yeast” that you say to use here? Are any of them the same? How does using one change the steps in the recipe?
Dana @ Minimalist Baker says
Instant and fast acting are the same! You can use any of them here, but the fast acting ones cause a quicker rise. Good luck!
Mercedes says
Hi, I just made this for the first time and it looks lovely! If I wanted to make a few loaves at a time and freeze them to reheat later, how would I go about doing that? Should I freeze the dough before cooking? Or cook and then freeze to reheat?
Dana @ Minimalist Baker says
Hmm, I would say freeze before cooking for best results! Let thaw before baking!
Mercedes says
Thanks! :)
Roxanne says
This is my second attempt at bread and it was delicious. The crust was prefect and the inside is moist and delectable. I accidently placed the oats in at the beginning and replaced the flax with hemp seeds and it all worked out. I also just made it as an artisanal round loaf.
Shilpa says
Hello Dana,
This was my first attempt to bake bread and it didn’t turned out to be success. The dough is uncooked from inside. The flour I used is multigrain flour. Could you please guide me so I can make it a success may be next time
James says
Knead more in the initial stage. I did Knead > 2 hour rise > punch > 2 hour fridge rise > punch > knead > rise > shape
Caroline says
I cannot find whole wheat pastry flour… is just regular whole wheat flour okay??
Caroline says
Please let me know:) I’m hoping to make it as soon as possible.
Megan says
I used spelt whole wheat flour (3 cups) and whole wheat white flour (3/4 cup). I live in Germany and these are the “normal” types of flours found at the supermarket. Also, you need to use the bread flour and not pastry flour! Otherwise it won’t rise properly!
Biljana says
Hello!
Thanks Dana for wonderful recipe!
I was wondering if sweetener is necessary? If yes, could it at least be substituted with oil or something?
Thanks!
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
Hi Biljana, the sugar feeds the yeast so we wouldn’t recommend leaving it out.
shilpa says
Hi Dana, can I use multigrain flour in this recipe like 3cups multigrain flour and 3/4 cup all purpose flour?
Second question is can I make bread completely with multigrain flour and not use any other flour in recipe?
Please help…this will be my first attempt to bake bread
Support @ Minimalist Baker says
Hi Shilpa, we haven’t tried that, but it might work. It will likely be more dense.
Ruby says
Can you use whole wheat flour instead of unbleached flour for this recipe?
Dana @ Minimalist Baker says
Check the comments, yes!
Tamara says
I don’t think it’s a different quantity.
Evelyn says
Hi, thanks for this recipe. I intend to try it tomorrow but I’m a little confused with where you said to add flour till its no longer sticky. Is this 3 3/4 extra flour different from the quantities listed in the ingredients? I ask because at the opening paragraph in directions, i thought all the flour went in with maple syrup etc before mixing commences. Please clarify
Thanks
Douglas says
I gotta tell ya, this is the best at home bread recipe. I added in more whole wheat flour (3 cups) and less white whole wheat flour (3/4 cups), about a tablespoon of honey and 7g of yeast, and added in the flax seeds with oats and nuts as I kneaded the bread before baking. This is my fourth loaf and the best yet. Thanks for the recipe!!! <3 :)
shilpa says
Hello, small query here. Did you meant to say you used 3 cups whole wheat four and 3/4 cup all purpose flour?
Douglas says
Yep!
Caroline says
did you use the pastry flour or just all whole wheat flour?
Jac says
Thank you for the recipe. This bread is almost artisan in look. I wish my grandmother had made me bread like this when I was a kid. Either way, homemade bread like this is so tasty. Thank you for sharing!
Suzanne says
Thanks for this recipe. I have been looking for an easy bread recipe that didn’t require hauling out the bread machine, and this is it! I make it almost weekly now…delicious.