Remember a few weeks back when I made coconut cream pie french toast? Well, this vegan mashed potatoes recipe came from the same place of inspiration: while I was working out watching the Food Network. Apparently, it’s my zen place.
Tyler Florence was making a version of mashed potatoes I’d never seen before. He cooked the potatoes in whole milk and cream to produce the creamiest, must luxurious mashed potatoes I’d ever laid eyes on. Obviously, I can’t do dairy because it hates me. So I wanted to try a vegan version to see if it worked sans cream.
Turns out, if you cook potatoes in unsweetened plain almond milk, it really just makes them kind of mealy and they taste like almond milk. Yick. Back to the drawing board. NOW YOU KNOW.
Another few attempts at the best damn vegan mashers yielded massive success. It turns out, you don’t need to cook them in anything other than plain old water. It’s the type of potatoes and mix-ins that make all the difference.
These mashers require 5 simple ingredients:
Yukon gold potatoes
Vegan butter
Roasted garlic (hubba. hubba)
Sea Salt
& Black Pepper
The result is super creamy, luxurious, dairy free mashed potatoes with a sweet garlic tone, plenty of S+P, and an herbaceous, light touch from the chives. Give me a spoon, I’m going in.
You will love these taters. They’re:
Thick
Fluffy
Creamy
Buttery
Airy light
Garlicky
Herbaceous
& Altogether satisfying
These mashed potatoes are perfection with a little additional vegan butter, salt, pepper and chives. But they would definitely stand up to and pair well with my 6-Ingredient Mushroom Gravy.
I also intended to make these into potato pancakes (inspired by the Inquiring Chef), but they just never made it that far. I literally ate half of them off of that spoon. OOPS. Sorry but not.
Enjoy!
What Goes with Mashed Potatoes
If you try this recipe, let us know! Leave a comment, rate it, and don’t forget to tag a photo #minimalistbaker on Instagram. Cheers, friends!
The Best Damn Vegan Mashed Potatoes
Ingredients
- 6-8 medium yukon gold potatoes (if large, cut in half)*
- 1 tsp sea salt (divided)
- Water to cover
- 1/2 tsp sea salt
- 1/2 tsp ground black pepper
- 5-6 cloves raw or roasted garlic (or sub minced garlic sautéed for 3 minutes in olive oil)*
- 3-4 Tbsp vegan butter (such as Earth Balance // melted/softened)
- 1/4 cup fresh chives (for topping // optional)
Instructions
- For creamier mashed potatoes, peel your potatoes at this time. Otherwise, just halve your potatoes and place in a large saucepan or pot and cover with water by ~1 inch.
- Bring to a light boil over high heat and add 1 tsp of sea salt (as original recipe is written // adjust if altering batch size), and cook for 25-30 minutes or until very tender. They should effortlessly slide off a knife when pierced with a knife.
- While the potatoes are cooking, chop up your chives (optional) and measure your vegan butter.
- Once tender, drain your potatoes and place them back in the hot pot off the heat for 1 minute to evaporate any additional water.
- Mash your potatoes using a potato masher until fluffy.
- Add in vegan butter, garlic, salt, and black pepper and stir to combine. Taste and adjust seasonings as needed.
- Lastly top with chives (optional, stir and serve as is or with your favorite gravy (or mushroom gravy). Leftovers will keep in the fridge covered for up to a few days. Not freezer friendly.
Video
Notes
*To roast a head of garlic, simply cup the top off to expose tips, rub with olive oil, wrap in foil and bake for 50 minutes – 1 hour in a 400-degree F (204 C) oven directly on the rack. Cloves should squeeze out easily once cooled. Discard skins/peel.
*Nutrition information is a rough estimate calculated with 6 yukon gold potatoes and the lesser amount of Earth Balance vegan butter.
Vicki Saunders says
Just to add to the variety of options, I make fat free mashed potatoes with fat free cream cheese (philly is best). I make vegan mashed potatoes with cashew cream. Just soak raw cashews in water, blend until very smooth, and cook until thick. The ratio of cashews to water depends on the degree of thickness that you want. Choose seasonings to taste. I make gravy or fondue with a ratio of 1/4 cup cashews per cup of liquid. (3/4 cups of cashews blended with 1 28 oz. can of green chili enchilada sauce and cooked until thickened, makes a great fondue type dip. also can be used as a sauce in a casserole.
robin says
Hi- would freezing these in advance of Thanksgiving be an option? I read somewhere you can freeze mashed potatoes in smaller portions- defrost and add some soy milk to rehydrate.
Thanks
Hi Robin! I haven’t frozen these. I would actually refrigerate them (up to 2 days in advance), and then reheat them in a 350 Degree oven on the day of!
Eric says
I made this yesterday for dinner with brisket. I think it’s a great recipe but to be honest, the Earth Balance gave the mashed potatoe a very noticable aftertaste that I did not care for. Next time I’ll replace the Earth Balance with olive oil. Earth Balance may work for some people really well, but for me it ruined the dish. I recommend try making it first with Earth Balance and if you don’t like how it taste, substitute next time with olive oil.
Ethel Humphreys says
If I make these just a few hours ahead (not a full day or two), wouldn’t they be okay heated in the microwave?
Yes, that should work!
Lisa Scott says
I have an issue with using the vegan butter as it always contains oil. What could I possibly use to make these potatoes creamy? Have you ever tried cashew cream or cashew mayo in these? I won’t use products that contain oil if it has been extracted from the fruit or not from which it was processed. Palm oil and coconut oil have more saturated fat than butter and I have found they drive up my cholesterol.
We haven’t tried either of those, but if you experiment, report back, Lisa!
Nikki says
I made these the other night with unsweetened cashew milk instead of butter and they were perfect!! You couldn’t taste the milk at all…cashew milk has a much more subtle taste than almond milk. I also used 4 Yukon gold potatoes and 2 red potatoes. Thanks for the recipe, these are the best vegan mashed potatoes I’ve had! :)
wendi says
how much cashew milk did you use??
Jennifer says
Literally the BEST vegan mashed potatoes I have had. I almost dipped out on the roasted garlic , but I am so glad that I didn’t. There is no need to modify this recipe. It was perfect. Thank you!!
Lola says
Way too much salt, anyone who plans on making it, I’d advise salt, taste and repeat until you like it. I followed the recipe and it’s way too salty.
Hi Lola, sorry to hear you found it too salty! We wonder if it may have had something to do with the type of salt used? Table salt tastes more salty than sea salt.
Breanna Martin says
Hi,
Just out of curiosity, how come you leave the potato skins on? Doesn’t that change the texture of the mashed potatoes?
Thanks
Fred says
Yes it does. It makes the texture better, more real (as opposed to powdered), and enriches the flavor (kind of like stepping up from vanilla ice cream to vanilla bean ice cream).
Ashley says
Which of your entrees would these mash potatoes be a good side for?
Hmm so many to pick from!! Have a browse here!
Jessica says
I would also like an approximate weight for the potatoes. That would be super helpful. Thanks!
~900 grams. Hope that helps!
Keturah says
I’m new to this no dairy mashed potato idea. I like to make my mashed potatoes ahead of time to minimize preparations the day of the event. Does anyone have experience with making this recipe a day or two before, refrigerating it, and baking/heating on the day of the event?
Keturah says
Never mind… I waded through the comments and found one that applies. I think I’ll try it!
Lindsey | This Miss Cooks says
I loved using yukon golds for mashed potatoes, though I suggest to anyone making it to do a better job than I did at cutting them up to equal sizes. ;)
Felicia says
Hi there! Just tested these out for Thanksgiving and they’re delish!! I’m concerned some guests may be picky with skin-on mashed potatoes. Can I peel the potatoes before boiling or would that affect the recipe in any way? Thanks!
Hi Felicia! Yes you can!
Mira says
I’d like to know if you cook potatoes with skin ? Whole ? Or, cut them in chunks ?
Thank you.
Hi Mira! We cook them skin on and whole, if they are large we suggest cutting them in half! Reference the photos in the post if you need!
Mira says
Thank you !! Thank you !!
Katie Linder says
Made these last night with red potatoes and sauteed garlic and they were AMAZING!! Even better as leftovers :) Simple and delicious recipe, thank you!
Glory says
What a delight! Everyone loved these potatoes! I added some almond milk to it to make it a bit creamier and made some gravy from vegan and gf bouillon cubes. Thanks for the recipe, I’ve been craving good mashed potatoes!
Elea says
An approximate weight would be helpful with the potatoes- i used three red skin instead and it turned out pretty good.
Hi Elea, thanks for the feedback! ~900 grams for 6-8 medium yukon gold potatoes.
Maegan says
Could you advise on the approximate weight of the 6-8 medium yukon gold potatoes? Just want to make sure I make this perfect the first time. ;-)
~900 grams
Jason says
So simple yet so tasty! I used small, red skinned potatoes and followed the recipe as directed. They turned out great and the whole family enjoyed. Thanks again!
Lauren says
I just made these and they’re delicious. I did add my own special touch though. It’s a family ingriedent that I grew up on. I grew up putting mayo in our mashed potatoes but since this is a vegan recipe I used veganaise. It gives it that perfect creamy consistently. It made them so yummy. Don’t believe me try it yourself
Elyse says
I made these. They are indeed incredible. I just wanted to say that instead of chives, I added the almond milk cream cheese by kite hill. Omg. So amazing. Creamy and delicious.
Kai says
I made these for thanksgiving and they were amazing! I still have some left over and would love to eat them, but I’m not sure how long they keep. When would you recommend to throw them out?
You can keep them for 4 days or so!
Jonathan says
On what planet do potatoes cook in 30 minutes? 1.5 hours and they still do not mash.
Did you peel and quarter them? 1.5 hours is WAY too long. In boiling water they should cook in 20-30 min.
Jessica Jones says
I live in high altitude and it doesn’t even take that long here. Make sure you are cutting the potatoes into small cubes before boiling
christine says
These are easily the best mashed potatoes, vegan or not, I’ve ever had. I agree that adding almond milk does make it slightly gummy so this recipe was a total success for me. The roasted garlic adds a TON of flavor and gold potatoes are soooo creamy. I brought this to a Family Thanksgiving and many people couldn’t believe this was vegan. Best Mashed Potatoes Ever!
Jenna says
THESE WERE AMAZING!! The one thing I have to say though is that I added a little bit of soy milk at the end to get a more creamy texture but the flavor was so so delicious. YAY vegan thanksgiving!! :)
Chriss Martorelli says
What’s wrong with adding almond milk? I use unsweetened almond milk in my cereal and it does not taste like almonds!
What does it supposedly do to mashed potatoes?
Hi Chriss, it probably depends on the brand of almond milk you use as some brands have a more pronounced almond flavor than others. A mild-flavored almond milk might be okay.
Becky says
I made these tonight and they turned out great! Thanks for the recipe and detailed instructions.
Jorie says
Justt made these in advance for Thanksgiing tomorrow- I doubled the recipe and it is DELICIOUS
Jenna says
This sounds great! I have heard of people adding a little mayo into their potatoes and it making a big difference but never tried it. I use Just mayo. If I added it, how much should I add? Also, do you think it would make them better to add a little almond milk if you’re used to using milk in them? Thanks ?
Hmm, not sure! Maybe 1 Tbsp to taste. And sure! But don’t add too much almond milk or it will taste like almond.
Jenna says
Thanks ? I decided to get soy milk instead.
Liz says
I made these today to determine which mashed potatoes I’ll make for Thanksgiving (these easily won!) I had leftovers today and decided to attempt some croquettes. I rolled these into tablespoon sized balls, dipped in almond milk, and then rolled in Pablo bread crumbs. I baked half of them at 350 for 20 min (flipping half way through) and fried the other half in inch of vegetable oil on stove. Both versions were delicious with pros and cons- baked croquettes didn’t brown and fried ones fell apart slightly. I’d still make both versions again though!
Grace says
I love adding carmelized onions and a bit of veggie broth to my mashed potatoes! Just kind of discovered it one night when I was craving mashed potatoes!
Mitchell Steiner says
Caramelized onions make ANYTHING taste better ;-)
Gram says
I made these mashed potatoes for my vegan granddaughter for Thanksgiving last year. I, also, made traditional mashed potatoes for our non-vegans. This year I’m only making the vegan mashed potatoes because they are amazing and much tastier.
Cj says
Can’t wait to try! I usually use a little warm broth and/or cook my potatoes in it too. Fresh basil with the roasted garlic is fabulous, by the way!
Bridget says
If you wanted to make these a day or two in advance would they still tasted as good, or better? Also, would you just warm them in a 350 oven for 20-30 minutes? Any info would be super helpful, thanks! :)
Hi Bridget! I think they’re best when fresh. But if you need to make ahead of time, reheat with a little more butter and plain almond milk as they tend to dry out when reheated. Good luck!
Zan says
I made a little variation of this recipe and it was delicious! Sweet potatoes, mixed in sautéed kale and a little tahini for extra protein.
Maddison says
Does anyone know if using russet potatoes would change the taste significantly? Thanks!!
Hi Maddison, it will impact the flavor and texture, but they will work!
Robyn says
I just made these and it was my first time ever making mashed potatoes! I halved the recipe and found them slightly dry so I cooked up a package of frozen spinach… it added moisture, more nutrients AND it’s delicious!
Megan says
You are adorable and your recipes are so fun to make & read!! Thank you!
Erin says
Instead of milk/cream in mashed potatoes, I’ve made these with cashew sour cream. (Cashews (soaked), Water, ice, lemon juice, salt in the vitamix). They are SO creamy and even the leftovers are creamy. No need to add more butter when reheating. They are phenomenal.
Fay says
What a beautiful site! I was looking for a vegan mashed potatoes recipe and stumbled across your site. Such a find for a new vegan such as myself.
Krystal says
Yummy! Best mashed potatoes for Christmas lunch. Thank you. I added a slash or two of almond milk because I like mine a little creamier.
Jazmin Lovenguth says
What type of vegan butter do you all use? I am also soy free so I am curious if anyone can recommend a brand? These look so amazing and I want to try making them!!
Krystal says
Earth balance makes a soy free butter.
Uncle Phil says
Pillowy mounds of mashed potatoes…
Suzanne says
Excellent! Had just these today and didn’t feel like I missed a thing!
Maggie says
These look delicious! Can they be made the night before and reheated in the oven?
Yes!
CA says
I made these- I didn’t have chives but I used truffle salt- very very very good! Thanks for sharing! :)
Jamie says
Hi Dana! I am Planning our first all vegan thanksgiving this year, I am so excited to try these out. I found your mushroom gravy and butternut sweet potato dish as well. I am making them all ?. I then decided I need your cookbook too. I had tried a cookie recipe of your awhile back and it was outstanding. Thank you for putting this out there for others in support of a more healthy sustainable future and less animal cruelty ❤️. Happy thanksgiving!
So kind! Thanks Jamie! xo
Ilana says
Hi! I just came across your website in a google search for “vegan mashed potatoes.” I’m not vegan, but my parents keep kosher so all our sides essentially have to be vegan. I was so excited to make this so I did last night, and I’ll definitely be making these again for Thanksgiving x 3! I also added some caramelized shallots, and omitted the chives as the shallot does the trick. I may add some green leaf for presentation on Thursday. This was delicious, thanks for sharing.
Ingrid says
Hey! This recipe looks delicious. I’m wondering if adding a bit of almond milk would make it taste too much like it. I wouldn’t boil the potatoes with it though. Also, does this taste too much like garlic??? I’m not too fond of a strong garlic taste. It seems like quite a bit of cloves.
Thanks! I hope to rate how it came out on Thanksgiving! :D ♡
Nope, a little almond milk won’t hurt. If you’re worried about the garlic, cut back in the beginning and add more later!
valerie says
Hi Dana, I’m preparing my first vegan Thanksgiving for a crowd of meat eaters. I will be making these mashed potatoes. Have you tried making them ahead and freezing them? I like to prepare thanksgiving dishes ahead of time and freeze to cut down on my time on the day of. I would be putting these in a large foil casserole size pan. Have any tips? will this work?
Hi Valerie! I haven’t frozen these. I would actually refrigerate them (up to 2 days in advance), and then reheat them in a 350 Degree oven on the day of!
Mollie says
Did you have any success freezing these?
HI Mollie, we haven’t tried freezing these, but think they would end up too watery.
Phyllis Davini says
I add garlic cloves to the potatoes as they are boiling. They just melt right in when I mash them with the potatoes. I also add about 1/2 C dairy free sour cream.
Kim says
So I know it says this recipe serves 4 but what are the portions like? I’ll be serving 15 and I don’t wanna look like a crazy lady making too much…then again Thanksgiving leftovers are the best thing in the world!
Michelle says
I cannot remember the last time I commented on a blog or forum ever in my life although I read them all day every day. I just wanted to let you know that I absolutely love your dishes and I plan my weekly meal plan around them. My family began eating healthy a few months ago after we found out my husband had health problems. I love the fact that most of your recipes are from one bowl, have few ingredients, and are quick. We have both lost a bunch of weight and feel so much better. I wanted to say thank you for sharing your talent with the world because we are better for it. Keep up the good work! If you were in front of me I would hug you. :)
Ah, thanks Michelle! So great to hear from you! Thanks for the kind words – made my day! xoxo
Sabrina says
I made these tonight and they were delicious! It was my older brother’s birthday so I made them for my whole family. Everybody loved them! Thank you!
Hannah says
My earlier efforts of vegan mashed potatoes always involved almond milk, and the texture was never right. These are fabulous. I used Earth Balance butter and 2-3 teaspoons minced garlic. I skipped the chives for topping, and served with Bush’s vegetarian baked beans. It was even a hit with animal product consumers in my family. I have made this recipe many times and recommend it!
angie s says
Delicious!!!! I’m kind of known for taking mashed potatoes to a new level, however, it involved (I now realize) disgusting amounts of dairy. We host Thanksgiving every year and we’re working on getting the perfect replacement recipes together for the big day and these will be the recipe I use!
Last night, we had these with a Seitan Piccata. It was vegan food Nirvana! The only changes made were to throw some smashed garlic into the water with the cooking potatoes (didn’t have any roasted and that’s just how I’ve always done it) and I mixed in some nooch as I was mashing it all (in the pan – I hate dishes). With potatoes and pasta, I always save a bit of the cooking water to add back if moisture is needed, and that came in really handy. Thank you for a great recipe!
Brooke says
I can’t believe these are vegan! One of the things I’ve learned about cooking vegan is that you don’t always need tons of ingredients. Like you mentioned, sometimes you just need something simple and easy and then add fixings to it later.
Danielle says
I adjusted the recipe by using red instead of yukon. At the end I added a smidge of unsweetened almond milk with the soy free earth balance. Turned out awesome!!
Yay! Thanks for sharing, Danielle!
Cara says
These were AMAZING!! My son just recently became vegan and I’ve made this recipe as well as your eggplant parm and pumpkin pie. Everything is soooo good and so easy!
With the eggplant parm, I ended up layering them in a casserole dish (like a lasagna) with tomato sauce and baked them to melt the cheese. Turned out great and brought it to dinner with non-vegans and everyone raved!
I LOVE this site and I’m looking forward to making more dishes! Thanks!
mimi says
are you telling me you don’t peel them before mashing???
Nope! You can peel off some, but I prefer skin on :D
Josh says
This came out perfectly for me :) delicious.
Era says
Made these for thanksgiving…and they will now be my go to recipe for mashed potatoes. Simple but sometimes the ‘less is more’ reminder is needed in the kitchen. Thank you for posting!
Tarin Almstedt says
I took half the butter and mixed in a tablespoon of miso paste, the stuff you make soup with, melted it in the micro and added that in. My wife could not figure out what it was, but she said it was good!
Katherine says
I made this dish for Thanksgiving today (my husband’s parents are vegan). It was so easy to make, and everyone loved the potatoes! The roasted garlic was an excellent touch. I will be making them again!
S R says
I followed your instructions but felt like mine came out super dry so I had to add milk to them to make them perfect consistency. My dinner guests thought they were delicious but I was looking forward to not having to add milk since I’m lactose intolerant but did it anyway because I didn’t want everyone to suffer from dry potatoes on my behalf
Chloe Mei says
Hi! I’m curious if adding almond milk to this recipe will enhance it in anyway? Last minute Thanksgiving question!
Hi Chloe, a small amount of almond milk should be fine. We just wouldn’t recommend using a lot, especially if it is a brand with a stronger flavor.
Samantha says
Thanks for this recipe, Dana! I want to try it tomorrow but am wondering if regular yellow potatoes will work just as well as the Yukon Gold or not. Did you try them? Thanks!
Yes, those would work!
Mel says
Love this idea! But… what can I substitute for vegan butter? Does olive oil work?
Thanks
Yes! Should work fine, but it will affect the flavor!
Carl says
Awesome, I made these vegan mashed potatoes for a friend of mine. I had no vegan butter handy so I used palm shortening and extra virgin olive oil, plus a little ground mustard. It was probably not as good as yours but pretty good. Key is the potatoes, really.
Ruben says
Made these for a work potluck and everyone raved about them…vegan or not. Such a simple yet delicious recipe. Thanks for sharing!
Cheryl says
If I’m not a fan of chunks of garlic in my food, do you think I could substitute garlic powder in this recipe, instead?
Cheryl says
I did find that I could use garlic powder instead of cloves.. leaving me to ask if you think a light vanilla-flavored Soy milk would overpower the taste of the potatoes? I know someone said no to Almond milk, and I’m not a fan of “Original” Soy milk, so what about a light vanilla-flavored Soy milk?
Hi Cheryl, we wouldn’t recommend a vanilla flavored milk in this recipe. We think the flavor will be overpowering.
Jennifer Houser says
Hello! How far in advance can I make these, for Thanksgiving dinner? And how would you recommend re-heating? Thanks!!
Hi Jennifer, we would recommend making them up to 2 days in advance and then reheating in a 350 degree oven on the day of!
mary says
these look so good, i’m going to try them. did you peel the potatoes?
Nope!
dmdezigns says
Looking forward to trying these. I’m test driving recipes for our family thanksgiving. My MIL is vegan and joining us, so the more things I can make vegan to start with, the less I have to make 2 of! Thanks for experimenting and giving me a starting point! I’ve got my southern green beans modified already. You’re right, earth balance is the bomb and a great substitute in the green beans for the bacon grease.
Steve Lassoff says
These mashed potaotes sound perfect! We shared them in a blog. We are building a vegan community and would love for you to hop over and leave a recipe.
Holly says
These are delicious! I never thought vegan mashed potatoes could taste so good without almond or soymilk, but they do!
Oh yay!!
rhiannon says
although it makes the potatoes a little dark looking, use black gatlic instead of regular garlic, omg garlicgasm!!!!
Anya G. says
Can I use almond milk instead of the Earth Balance. How healthy/natural is vegan butter
Hi Anya, a little unsweetened plain almond milk might be okay, but we wouldn’t recommend leaving out the vegan butter. You could try subbing olive oil instead. Hope that helps!
Ally says
I made these for my dad on Father’s Day and him and my whole family ate them up! I am an aspiring chef and I love to use this website for ideas and to use the recipes.
Yay! So glad you enjoyed them. Cheers!
Kelly says
When do you add the garlic???
After the mash with the butter! I’ve just fixed it in the recipe. Thanks!
Kimberly says
Thank you Dana for another awesome recipe. My family loved the vegetable pot pie….These yummy potatoes will be on rotation this week. Please keep the vegan recipes coming!
Will do! Thanks for sharing!
kaly s-b says
my boyfriend makes the most insane vegan mashed potatoes and the recipe is similar–the secret is a teeny bit of veganaise. it’s hard to watch him make them (so much e.b!) but once in a while they’re such a tasty treat.
Jenna says
How much vegan mayo does he add? I use Just mayo and I’ve heard of people putting a little mayo in mashed potatoes before but never tried it. Also, do you think Adding a little almond milk would make it better if you’re used to using milk in them?
Kelly says
I always use almond milk in my mashed and never thought they were mealy. I do boil the milk first before adding, if that makes a difference. Or maybe I’m just used to the mealy taste. I can’t wait to try your recipe. Thank you!
Clever Girl Reviews says
Those look great, next time I have a dish that calls for mashers on the side, I’ll give this a try.
Lily (A Rhubarb Rhapsody) says
I love, love, LOVE roasted garlic! I’m not vegan but always have Nuttelex (vegan butter) in the fridge as well as some top notch real butter. My mashed potatoes usually have an obscene amount of real butter and cream in them so this would definitely be a much healthier option. :)
It’s kind of scary how much butter, cream cheese and cream you can hide in mashed potatoes. So good, but SO heavy. Glad alternatives yield similar if not better results!
Crista says
those DO look amazing!
carole @ carolebeefoodandphoto.com says
These look AMAZING! I too have made the error of putting almond milk… bleh! So gross!! LOL
Roasted garlic and vegan butter + potatoes… ALL good in my books!!
If you add crispy fried onions to the top of these it will BLOW your mind!! SO yummy!!
WHOA. Crispy fried onions on top? I just squealed out loud. Great tip, Carole!
Lisa | Je suis alimentageuse says
Thank you for experimenting for us haha. Now I know not to try to cook potatoes in almond milk. Love this recipe, love the photos, and love the roasted garlic comment (hubba hubba) XD
Because I am tooootally on the same page.
Kathryn says
It’s great to know that you can still get that fluffy buttery mashed potato effect from vegan butter! And the roasted garlic just takes these over the top delicious.
Kate says
Your “NOW YOU KNOW” made me laugh so hard I snorted wine out of my nose. True story.
Thanks so much for sharing these! It’s always frustrating for me (though a non-vegan) to discover that something that should, in theory, be perfectly vegan, is not. I may need to try these!
This made my day. If I can make one person snort wine out of their nose while reading my blog, I have accomplished much :D Thanks for sharing, Kate! Hope enjoy this recipe!
Sarah @ Sarah Cooks the Books says
I don’t think I’ve ever craved mashed potatoes before. . .until now.
Mission: accomplished. :D
Amanda @ Once Upon a Recipe says
I’m totally going to make these for all the non-vegan-believers in my life to show them that you don’t need butter or cream to make amazing mashed potatoes! These seriously look incredible!
Ceara @ Ceara's Kitchen says
This brought the biggest smile to my face: “while I was working out watching the Food Network. Apparently, it’s my zen place.” haha!!! Can I just say, I understand what you mean 100% ! And these look fantastic – so making them for my next holiday get together.
We have the same zen place. This is internet fate :D Thanks for saying hi, Ceara!
Shikha @ Shikha la mode says
Wow, look at that yellow color – so so great, and healthier too!
Jess says
I’m not sure I could have managed to resist long enough for potato pancakes either, Dana! These look SO good.
Lindsay Moe says
These do look dreamy! I have not tried vegan butter. Would you put it on par with vegan cheese (not my favorite)? I guess I’m not vegan, so I could always just use regular butter. :)
Vegan butter tastes JUST like real butter in every way. Earth Balance is where it’s at. But if you can have dairy, just do real butter!
E says
“Melt” is also really yummy. It’s more difficult to find, though.
Gomez says
I’m in my way 50s and I tasted that melt, and I’ve been vegan my whole life and it was the most horrible tasting stuff ever. You have got a tough pallet if you can eat that. I like the no soy Earth Balance. what’s really strange is they make I’m mainstream strange margarine and within that mainstream one they just came out with a new one called vegan. And they came out with a new one called organic. But as far as I know they did not combine the two. Very confusing wine it not just go vegan organic?
rachel says
I thought the same thing! Why is it either/or? Can’t have my organic vegan margarine? The unfortunate aspect of most vegan butter though is the use of palm oil :( a good option might be to make your own vegan butter (if your confident like that) or opt for pasture raised, no growth hormones, grass fed butters.
Sheryl says
Where can you find this butter? My niece can’t have lactose would like to make these potatoes
Hi Sheryl! Most grocery stores should carry it!
Ann says
Trader Joe’s sells “Miyoko’s Creamery European Style Cultured VeganButter” which is made from organic coconut oil and organic cashews and it tastes and spreads just like real butter…good luck!
LIESEL BIMMERLE says
LOVE Miyoko’s! It is my fav vegan butter by far…
Susan says
Miyoko’s is great! I’m not vegan but cook for vegan family members.
SJ says
Yes they worked great! I added some flax seeds meal, nutritional yeast and garlic powder to make it extra savory ?
Illy says
This is a beautiful butter, but a bit more costly than Earth Balance. I reserve Miyokos for m morning toast. However, Miyoko has a recipe for butter that I will be making soon! It’s so much more affordable. I don’t know what I would do without The Minimalist Baker and Miyoko Schinner. My absolute 2 faves!
dayna vogt says
trader joes now has a terrific vegan cultured butter – tastes better than Earth Balance and MELT, BTW is not vegan. It is vegetarian but not vegan…..
BC says
Melt IS Vegan – right on the package
Christina says
I just found it at Kroger!
Stephanie G says
I’m sitting upstairs listening to my family eat Thanksgiving dinner without me. Post op cramps from
Surgery on Monday. Sucks. But I’m already planning my redo turkey dinner including these mashed potatoes. And I agree. Earth Balance is so good you’ll probably never want butter again. Dairy hates me too.
Chanel says
Can I use ghee in place of vegan butter ? Or would that change the consistency/taste?
We think that would work!
Ginny says
All vegan cheeses are not created equal. It’s like finding your Prince Charming, you have to kiss alot of frogs before you find your prince. I recommend Trader Joe’s vegan soy mozzarella and sliced wrapped cheddar cheese. I’ve tried different shredded varieties of mozzarella cheese and they don’t melt or brown well. Try these out and you may find out you’re a closet vegan!
SFerd says
One note of caution regarding TJ’s Soy Mozzarella–it does NOT freeze well. It basically turns into little crumbs. So, if (like me) you tend to throw your shredded vegan cheez into the freezer, purchase another brand. Daiya freezes well.
The Heidi Ho! brand of spreadable goat-style cheez is super tasty on bruschetta with fresh chopped tomatoes & basil.
Mari says
Earth balance spread is the way to go. Spreads like butter, tastes like butter. I only wished it came in a bigger size.
Kenz says
They come in HUUUGE sizes at Costco!
Paul says
I’m planning on making a Tofurkey roast with mashed potatoes and cranberry sauce for my girlfriend tonight (she’s vegan, I’m omnivore). This is easily the best looking vegan mashed potatoes recipe I found. I’d heard of Earth Balance but never had it myself. After reading this recipe I picked some up at the local grocery store, and tried some when I got home. I swear, I’m switching to it myself. It tastes SO good. Better than my “healthy but real” butter that I usually use. Definitely give Earth Balance a try.
Chuck says
Field Roast Celebration Roast is so much better than Tofurky.
J Peterson says
Which Earth Balance works best with this though? There are spreads and sticks, buttery and shortening. AHH!!
The butter stick or spread in the tub is best!
Jennifer says
I am new to using vegan butter and I actually feel it tastes better than regular butter. It has a richer taste in my opinion.
Abbie @ Needs Salt says
Wow these mashed potatoes look so good. Can I have a spoon, too?
Pinned!
Donna says
Having a potato/glycemic index PHOBIA…alas….I am SOOO going to try this exactly as you have prepared it…but with celery root/celeriac instead!…Your images simply invite one to grab the nearest (large) spoon!
Gomez says
Remember cauliflower works this way also! Steemit well rather than boil. You could do 95% cauliflower and 5% potato. The Yukon Golds have a different kind of starch they’re considered waxy. Something else I found out if you eat black beans preferably home-made not from a can with potatoes it cancels out the reaction of starch in the typical manner of turn into sugar, IE the reaction with your pancreas. Something about the fiber in black beans just compliments potatoes like crazy it can even stand up to the russets which are super starch and turn to sugar. I found that my body accepts them really well if I have the black beans with it! It’s fantastic! And any of the nut milks if made properly added towards the end in a small amount will cream things up. I love my potatoes and garlic. I pretty much love garlic and anything. I use a shocking amount
Jamie says
Haven’t had a chance to make this exact recipe. But I do know almond milk didn’t compliment the potatoes at all. I will try the coconut milk next time. Would you recommend using canned for this?
@Gomez This is some great info! I have an awful time processing potatoes. Maybe the homemade pot of black beans will help me too. I have so many sensitivities to foods. Anything, and everything like this is super helpful. ?
Rikki says
Yeah, almond milk is just an all-around pretty terrible nut milk when compared to all the rest of the nut milks. I find unsweetened soy to be wonderful to cook with–and for everything else!
Maryea {happy healthy mama} says
I totally agree that Yukon golds make the best mashed potatoes. And no to almond milk in them–I’ve also tried that plenty of times. It just does not work. I love your add-ins, as well. The roasted garlic seems like it would take these to the next level.
Christine says
Has anyone ever tried adding coconut milk?
Alejandra says
Yes and it’s delicious! I saute garlic, ginger and finely chopped cauliflower in coconut oil and then I mash this into the potatoes and add a can of coconut milk for the creamy factor. This was a hit at my house and the coconut taste is very subtle….Ginger in there is really nice too.
Rikki says
Omg that sounds amazing! I have some coconut cream that’s about to go bad… Maybe I should give that a shot. I wouldn’t think to add cauliflower, but that sounds great too.
Ashley says
I’ve never made the mashed potatoes in this recipe but every time I make them I use coconut milk. Turn out delicious every time! This year for thanksgiving I’m making the mashed potatoes with macadamia nut milk bc since my father in law is allergic to coconut and I don’t have to make two batches! I’m hoping it will turn out just as good, seeing as I haven’t tried it this way before! :)
Rikki says
Oooh, macadamia nut milk is DIVINE!
Luisa says
I add coconut cream (chilled full-fat coconut milk from a can) to all my mashed potato dishes. I feel as though it’s a great alternative to the heavy cream used in traditional recipes. It makes them very creamy and smooth, and I personally can’t taste the coconut flavor at all.
Melissa Muik says
Oh wow I love almond milk in ours!!!