I know. It’s still technically winter, you guys. But in the Northwest, it’s practically spring! There are literally trees blooming outside our window. I could faint from excitement.
Plus, you know how I feel about dessert. Thus the reason we must ice cream.
Yes, ice cream is now a verb. Get on board.
This ice cream was inspired by the best vegan ice cream on the planet, which happens to be scooped up right here in Portland at Salt and Straw.
If you’re ever in the area, you must try their coconut caramel ice cream with chocolate candy chunks. It’s what vegan ice cream dreams are made of.
The best part about this recipe? It requires only 7 ingredients, and it’s naturally sweetened!
I opted to forgo the chocolate candy bar pieces because I’m a purist (or lazy). But in my opinion, it’s so close to the original that if blindfolded I may not be able to tell the difference between their version and mine. I think this is love.
I was half tempted to try a sugar-based vegan caramel sauce, but I realized my sea salt date caramel was a very good thing. Date caramel is entirely natural, quick, easy, and requires just 2 ingredients. TWO.
Add bourbon at your own discretion. But c’mon. A little won’t hurt.
This ice cream is delicious like WHOA. It’s:
Creamy
Luxurious
Perfectly sweet
Salted caramel-infused
Rich
Satisfying
SIMPLE
& Seriously amazing
I have another recipe coming soon that utilizes this ice cream to recreate one of my favorite desserts of all time. Any guesses? I gave you guys a sneak peek on Instagram a couple weeks ago and can’t wait to share! Sit tight to see what I came up with. It’s gonna blow your dessert-loving mind.
If you try this ice cream, please let us know! Take a picture and tag us on Twitter or #minimalistbaker on Instagram! We’d love to see what you come up with. Cheers!
Sea Salt Caramel Coconut Ice Cream
Ingredients
COCONUT ICE CREAM
- 1 1/2 cups raw cashews (soaked for 4-6 hours in cool water, or 1 hour in very hot water, then drained)
- 1 15-ounce can full-fat coconut milk (sub light with less creamy results)
- 3 Tbsp melted coconut oil
- 1/2 cup maple syrup or agave nectar (sub up to half with cane sugar)
- 1 tsp pure vanilla extract
- 1 pinch sea salt
SALTED DATE CARAMEL
- 14 whole dates (pitted // if dry, soak in warm water for 10 minutes, then drain)
- 1/2 tsp sea salt
- 1-3 Tbsp warm water (optional // for thinning)
- 1 Tbsp bourbon (optional)
Instructions
- The night before, place your ice cream churning bowl in the freezer to properly chill. Also, make sure you soak your cashews overnight OR the next day for at least 6 hours. Be sure to drain before adding to blender.
- Add soaked, drained cashews, coconut milk, coconut oil, maple syrup, vanilla and sea salt to a high speed blender and blend until creamy and smooth, scraping down sides as needed. Use the “liquify” setting if you have it. You want it to be completely creamy and blended.
- TIP: For best texture, chill mixture for at least 4-6 hours or preferably overnight. If you're in a rush, pop it in the freezer for 1-2 hours before adding to ice cream maker. Otherwise, proceed without chilling - it will just take longer to churn and may require extra chilling (see next step).
- Add chilled mixture to ice cream maker and churn according to manufacturer’s instructions - about 45 minutes. It should look like soft serve. If it wasn't chill enough, it may not firm up during the churning process. In that case, pop it back in the freezer (still in the churning bowl) and freeze until mostly firm. Then churn once more.
- In the meantime, prepare caramel by adding dates to a food processor or blender and blending until creamy and smooth, adding warm water to encourage it along if it needs extra help. Season with sea salt (and bourbon if desired) and blend once more to combine. Taste and adjust flavor as needed. Set aside.
- Once churned, transfer the ice cream to a large freezer-safe container and spoon in desired amount of caramel (I used it all, but you can reserve it for other uses) and use a spoon or knife to swirl. Add a pinch more salt for even more salty-sweet contrast if desired.
- Smooth top and cover well. Freeze for at least 4-6 hours or until firm.
- Set out for 10-15 minutes before serving to soften. Will keep for up to 1 week, though best when fresh.
Notes
*Prep time does not include soaking, chilling, and freezing.
Nancy D. says
I made this last weekend. First the caramel is amazing and mandatory. I saved the extra for my morning yogurt.
I chilled the ice cream base for about 6 hours and it was almost solid-diffilcult to pour into the machine. I think the ice cream maker was not able to churn effectively. The flavor was amazing, just not the smoothest consistency. Next time I will only chill for 1-2 hours.
Thanks for sharing, Nancy!
Adrienne says
Love this recipe. Huge hit at the office. I’m a long, long time user of the site and have made more recipes than I can count (so many favorites are memorized now). First time with this one and followed it to the letter, even “borrowing” a shot of bourbon from my boss. Only a few people knew it was vegan and refined-sugar free. But everyone said it was one of the best ice creams they’ve ever had and some, once they found out that about it being dairy and sugar free, went and had seconds. It was all gone before long. The one note is that I wouldn’t leave the base sitting in the freezer too long. My workhorse of a Kitchen Aid mixer refused to stir when the ice cream frozen overnight. A different machine might be better with the base so solid, but I seriously thought at one point that my ice cream mixing components were permanently broken. Had to give it 30 minutes to an hour sitting in the counter and then tried again. Once softened, it was absolutely straightforward from there.
Thank you so much for sharing your experience, Adrienne! We are so glad you enjoy our recipes! xo
Tammy Rosecrans says
I’m trying the recipe out now and need some help – I used my food processor on low instead of a blender, but right before it got to the creamy texture, it started to curdle. Can I fix it!?
OK, what type of coconut milk did you use? Apparently some are more prone to curdling than others.
Tammy says
I used Thai Kitchen brand. I’ve been keeping the mix in the fridge – is there anything I can do to save it?
Hmm, I’m not sure. We actually just had someone mention their Thai Kitchen curdled which makes me think it’s a brand issue. Try Savoy or Aroy-D next time!
Mandrea says
I’m attempting this without an ice cream machine. When do you suggest adding in the salted caramel sauce?
Hi Mandrea, we haven’t tried it, but we would suggest adding it at the same time as if using an ice cream maker. Because it’s so thick/rich you might be able to get away without churning. We’d recommend taking it out of the freezer several times while it’s firming up and whipping it with a whisk or beater. Let us know if you try it!
Plisca says
Hi, I’m wondering if it would work to use cashew butter (100% cashews) instead of soaked cashews. Thanks!
Hmm, we haven’t tried that, but it might be too thick. Let us know if you try it!
Madonna Nash says
This ice cream was delicious. The bourbon added to the caramel was a nice touch!! Paired well with your Snickerdoodle Cookies!! Yummy. Can’t wait to try the Vegan Bourbon Ice Cream.
Thanks so much for the lovely review, Madonna. We are so glad you enjoyed it! Next time, would you mind leaving a rating with your review? It’s super helpful for us and other readers. Thanks so much! Xo
GABRIEL JAMES MURRAY says
Hi There!
Would it be possible to substitute cashew butter for the soaked cashews to get a less gritty result?
Hi Gabriel, Hmm, maybe- but it could be too dense. A high-speed blender should get them very creamy!
Megan says
Followed method to the tee, using my Vitamix. Amazing, creamy, and every who eats this asks for the recipe. I’ve found that adding a drizzle of coconut nectar, vanilla, and nut milk to the date caramel takes it to the next level. The ice cream itself it amazing as is!
Thanks for sharing, Megan!
Linda Nienhuis says
Wow, Awesome. Started making this yesterday and actually followed the directions letting it set over night. Today when I put it in my little electric Gelato maker, haha it only went 7 minutes before the motor said NO MORE. But it was done. I put it in the freezer after doing the caramel swirl and 4 hours later, just now I had to sample. May I say, Oh my goodness. I have saved this recipe for birthdays only however. 5 STARS!!
We’re so glad you enjoyed it, Linda! Thanks for sharing!
Holly says
Hi. You mentioned you were going to try a sugar-based caramel sauce? Do you have a recipe for one that would work here? My daughter is not a big fan of dates.
How about this one? Or this one…?
Daryl says
By far the best vegan ice cream I have ever made. The texture and flavor were perfect! I added the salted date caramel into the machine when my Breville says to introduce add-ins and so there wasn’t a swirl, but it was still amazing. I will definitely make this again.
We’re so glad you enjoyed it, Daryl! Thanks so much for sharing!
bella says
Hi, for the cane sugar sub how much of it needed for this recipe? half? thank you :)
Hi Bella, you mean adding cane sugar instead of maple syrup? Yes, 1/2 cup. Let us know how it goes!
Sofia says
Hello! I would like to know, if it’s possible to make it last longer than a week. Also, I if I add guar gum would there be any inconvenience??
Yeah, if it’s covered well it should last up to 1 month. Will adjust that in the recipe! If you add guar gum that should only make it creamier! That or xanthan I’ve heard does well in ice creams to mock eggs.
Gracia Larson says
I’m excited to try this recipe but I don’t have an ice cream maker…any suggestions on what to use instead?
Hi Gracia, because it’s so thick/rich you might be able to get away without using an ice cream maker. We’d recommend using a parchment-lined loaf pan and taking it out of the freezer several times while it’s firming up and whipping it with a whisk or beater. Good luck! Let us know if you give it a try!
Jennifer says
I love this recipe! Also use it to make my own ice cream sandwiches with pecan flour brownies as the outside layer.
Yum! Thanks so much for the lovely review, Jennifer. We are so glad you enjoyed it! Next time, would you mind leaving a rating with your review? It’s super helpful for us and other readers. Thanks so much! xo
Tj khaw says
Hi. For the recipe. Raw Cashews is 1 and 1/2 cups or 1/2 cup? Thks
Hi TJ, it’s 1 and 1/2 cups. Hope that helps!
Frida Navarrete says
Hi, how much coconut milk is asked in the recipe i don’t understand the 1 – 15 ounce. Does it means is 15 ounces or 115?
Hi Frida, this recipes requires one 15-ounce can. Hope that helps!
Heather says
Ok I thought I might add my suggestion here about the caramel sauce! I read though all the comments before making everything. I decided to follow the instructions first with the dates and see if it worked for me because I have a Blendtec. Well mine didn’t turn out either :-( so then I thought let me try this on the stove and see what happens. So I put about 1/2 cup chopped dates with 1/4 cup almond milk and brought to bubbling. Got out my whisk and went to town! The dates started dissolving and the almond milk absorbing into this thick carmely goodness. But I still had bits of date so, I pulled out the food processor, scraped it in there and turned it on for about 1-2 min. Bingo! Carmel sauce success!
Thanks for sharing, Heather!
Natalie says
Oh my goodness, this ice cream was AMAZING! I followed the directions exactly and I’m sure that’s why it turned out so well. Thank you for this recipe!!
Graciela says
This recipe is INCREDIBLE, and I am extremely picky about ice cream! Thanks Dana for another amazing recipe… Huge crowd pleaser every time!
I make this for Thanksgiving and Christmas (as well as well as Tuesdays, bank holidays, and any other day I make up an excuse to indulge lol); and I usually have to hide some of it for the rest of the week, because it is immediately devoured every time.
My only mods are to the caramel:
I soak my dates in warm almond milk (instead of water) to soften them… This makes the almond milk so sweet and delicious and date flavored. Then I drain the dates, saving the date-flavored almond milk when I do so, and I use THAT to thin the caramel instead of water. I also add a dash of vanilla. I have found that using the date-sweetened almond milk for thinning with a dash of vanilla makes the caramel even richer and creamier than using water :)
If any is left over, I drink it or make it into a latte, because it is so amazing!
I also half the salt in the caramel to start with and add more from there… depending on the size of your dates, you could end up with way too much salt if you start out with the full 1/2 teaspoon if using smaller dates.
Happy Eating, ya’ll <3
Lenna Storm says
Oh. Em. Gee. I made this ice cream for a family gathering, and it was a home run. Love the caramel sauce, but the ice cream itself is amazeballs. I actually added a teaspoon of vanilla bean powder and instead of bourbon, I added spiced rum. :) It might be too rich for every day use, so I’ll either reduce the maple syrup or the cashews. But overall, this was absolute heaven. Thanks Dana!!! You have become one of my absolute favorite sources for tasty and healthier fare. Keep up the good work!!!
Thanks so much for the review, Lenna! We are glad to hear that it was a hit!
Jackie says
This is absolutely delicious. My whole family loved it.
My ice cream maker is on its last legs and didn’t churn properly, so I put the mix into silicone push-up lolly tubes…..wonderful!!!!
Gorgeous balance of flavours…..Thank you!
Christine says
Looks so amazing, can’t wait to try it! What is the purpose of adding the additional melted coconut oil? Can I use coconut cream instead of coconut milk and just omit the additional coconut oil? Thanks!!!
The melted coconut oil creates a creamy texture! You could use olive oil in place of coconut oil, but I wouldn’t recommend omitting it entirely. You can use coconut cream in place of coconut milk though!
Carly says
What brand of full fat coconut milk would be the best for this recipe?
We recommend this one!
Julie Redmond says
Is it possible to make this recipe without an ice cream machine. I would love one but no room in my kitchen… Too many gadgets already. ?
Hi Julie! Hmm, because it’s so thick/rich you might be able to get away without churning. We’d recommend taking it out of the freezer several times while it’s firming up and whipping it with a whisk or beater. Good luck!
Patty says
So glad I tried this ice cream, it was delicious. The Carmel sauce is genius. My husband love it, too. Thank you.
Ashley says
I made this without an ice cream maker and it was amazing..like to die for! I just followed the freezing guides of the No Churn Chocolate Vegan Ice cream recipe! So so good! Thank you for sharing!
Susan says
Something went wrong for me, too. I blended the cashews in a Vitamix, so the texture was fine. I refrigerated the mixture overnight (as suggested in the recipe) and when I took it out it was THICK. It was as if it was congealed. So it was impossible for the ice cream freezer to churn it. It’s a cuisinart ice cream maker and I’ve made LOTS of ice cream in it in the past, but I’ve always poured a custard into it. I wonder if I poured it in directly from the Vitamix instead of refrigerating it. I had made it for company, but didn’t end up serving it.
Sarah Spano says
Hi there, just wondering if I can make this without an ice cream maker? I have a Thermomix if I could use that instead?
Hmm we have not tried making it with a Thermomix but because it’s so thick/rich you might be able to get away without churning. I’d recommend taking it out of the freezer several times while it’s firming up and whipping it with a whisk or beater. Good luck!
Don Lee says
I tried making this for my grandkids but it did not pass their taste test. I think it has to do with the flavor from the blended cashews.
Sabrina says
Hi :)
Can you also make this without an ice cream maker?
Thanks in advance,
Sabrina
Hi! Hmm, because it’s so thick/rich you might be able to get away without churning. I’d recommend taking it out of the freezer several times while it’s firming up and whipping it with a whisk or beater. Good luck!
Ashley says
Hi! I just tried this recipe for the first time and I don’t know what went wrong. I blended the mixture in my blender and put it in the fridge overnight. It was smooth when I put it in the fridge, and still smooth but very thick when I took it out in the morning. I had left it on the counter for 10 minutes while I was preparing the ice cream machine and dates, and when I looked the mixture had turned from smooth and thick, to grainy (tiny white flecks). I tried blending it again and it stayed grainy. So the end result was grainy ice cream after churning it in the machine. It still tasted decent, just a grainy texture. Where did I go wrong? Should I have immediately placed the super thick mixture from the fridge into the machine?
Penny Kingan says
So delicious. I have high speed blender so didn’t have any problems with graininess. Love swirling through the caramel at the end : ) Thanks!
Belinda says
Hi Dana,
I tried a recipe like this but the cashews tasted ‘grainy’. Any tips? Maybe I need a new blender.
Thanks, Belinda
Hi Belinda! It may be the blender yes and it may not be chopping the cashews down enough.
Alka says
Hi Dana, this looks great! But I see a problem was with the dates. Whenever I blend dates it turns out more choppy and doughy than smooth..any suggestions?
Hi Alka! I am thinking it might be your blender not chopping the dates up quite enough! Try to pulse and blend longer and see if that helps, otherwise I would test with a different blender.
Ellie says
Hi Dana,
I am wondering what kind of ice cream churner or maker do you have? Love your blog and your book.
Thank you for continuing to share you creativities in making nutritious and delicious food.
Your reader,
Ellie
Hi Ellie! This one!
Ellie says
Thank you so much for replying! Just order one through Amazon! I am very excited to embark my homemade ice cream journey using your recipes.
Sreya says
Could we use a blender for the ice cream, or does it have to be churned in an ice cream maker?
Check the other comments as others have already asked this! Good luck!
sofia says
This is my 5th vegan ice cream recipe attempt/recipe and unfortunately this is not the one for me either. When I don’t put cashews in the base, it’s all icy and watery, but this just tasted like puréed cashews in my opinion. It’s not a bad recipe, just wasn’t something I enjoyed. Maybe I should play around some more with the cashew/coconut milk proportion.
Emilly says
Hello, I would love to make this ice-cream & many others on your blog, but I am allergic to cashews. Do you have any suggestions for what I should do instead. Also pine nuts or macadamia nuts will not work for me either :( thank you !
Hmm, you could probably omit it and double up on coconut milk – just make sure it’s full fat. Also add some cornstarch or arrowroot and twice the vanilla to cut down on crystallization! Good luck!
deb says
i am struggling with the date caramel sauce. my dates were very soft and i have a blendtec blender that is very good and strong. however i’ve added MUCH more water to this than the 3 tbs *now up to 1/2 cup* is this really supposed to be a smooth sauce or kinda of chunky? would appreciate some feedback – thank you. ps – i’m reallllllllly wanting this to turn out!! : )
deb says
well this caramel sauce has been VERY time consuming, because i had to use a sieve to get all the date skins off *who wants that in the caramel sauce – not me lol*, this took much longer than originally posted. i am hoping it’s going to be worth it. and i’m not going to use the cashews either – after all this work i certainly don’t want a granular icecream :)
Candice says
This takes way longer than an hour!
Kristin Baker says
Excellent, especially with the bourbon added. ;)
I also used a Vita-mix which definitely improves the texture of the ice cream considering cashews are used for half of the base.
Ankita says
Okay ? Thank you so much fo your reply! ??? You are awesome!!!
Ankita says
Hi Dana! Can we freeze any loaf pans be it of Bakers secret (I want to make your cheesecake recipe too) or Chicago metallic one? Or I have to buy anything specific
I think any container will do!
AS says
Ok so I’ll be the first person to leave a review of this recipe who’s actually made it!! The flavour is absolutely delicious but because the food processor does not liquefy the cashews and the ice cream texture turned out very “grainy”. I found this very annoying when eating it and it also took away from the creamy texture. I did notice someone else had asked if store bought cashew milk could be used but there was response from the author. I’m not sure if the cashews play a important part in the process but next time I think I will leave it out.
GT says
dear AS . the icecream turned out great without the cashews – as i felt you definitely had a great point, and i decided to heed your advice. cheers and hope you get to make it again without the cashews!
Tabi says
I’m not vegan or vegetarian, but this is now my favorite ice cream of all time. :) It’s not a replacement or substitute for ice cream, it’s better than real ice cream, it’s that good.
Emma M says
I tried this recipe and the result is amazing! I added a few pinches of Xanthan Gum for extra stretchiness and used coconut sugar as the sweetener. I’ve made so many failed attempts at so many healthy ice cream recipes, and this is a successful one! I’d love to try out some of your other ice cream recipes. Thank you for this wonderful recipe XX
Sharon says
What will happen if I omit churning? Can it be mixed with a mixer Instead? I don’t have an ice cream maker and can’t handle another kitchen appliance. I already have way too many. The recipe looks too good to not try. Thanks.
Marcus L. says
Hi Dana! This seems like an awesome recipe! I have been trying out several coconut milk based recipes and have recently tried on cashew-coconut based one. However, every time i get it out of the freezer, it seems that there are some noticeable ice crystals that form. Do you have any advice for how to prevent that from happening with this recipe? Thaaanks!
Shannon says
So I put my mixture into the freezer for 4 hours – took it out to put it into our ice cream maker and it is solid as a rock. How do you put it into the ice cream maker to churn? It said to freeze for 4-6 hours
Thanks
Shannon
Hmm, 4 hours in the freezer is too long. It only needs to chill for about 1 hour in the freezer OR 4-6 hours in the REFRIGERATOR.
Shannon says
Ahhh. The fridge is the place I messed up. Thanks so much!!!
cathy says
I would love to make this with soy milk instead of coconut milk. how much can I replace it with?
Rachel says
Hi! Quick question- can I use my food processor to blend the soaked cashews instead of a blender? I know some of the commenters complained of a gritty texture and I don’t own a high-powered blender.
AS says
I used a food processor and the texture still turned out gritty. Will probably leave out the cashews next time.
Elsa Cline says
Hi! Would the “coconut beverage” that Trader Joe’s sells in the carton work instead of the canned coconut milk? Do you know if they are the same thing?
Unfortunately, no. The fat content is too low.
Melissa says
Would like to do this! Looks gorg! But I don’t have an ice cream maker. Is there a substitute?
Stacie says
O..M..G!!! This stuff is AMAZING!!! I make a lot of vegan ice cream at home and this is BY FAR the best I’ve ever made! I used 50/50 simple syrup and honey since I didn’t have any maple syrup. I also used store bought caramel and added chocolate chopped chunks. Just the ice cream base though is absolutely fantastic! Thanks you SOOOO much for the recipe. I was having a hard time finding the So Delicious Salted caramel ice cream in the store, and this is even better!
Just a note: This froze in my ice cream maker without any chilling in only ~18 min, much faster than usual.
Elena says
Just bought my ice cream maker…so do it still have to add rock salt and ice into it, on top of your mentioned ingredients?
Elena says
Fyi… I just bought my ice cream maker so please disregard my question. I fell deep into the art of buying appliances.
Tip #1: For those of you who don’t know, just because it’s an electric IC maker, doesn’t mean it doesn’t need ice. I exchanged the pretty looking vintage ice cream maker for a Cuisinart, which will not require buying ice and rock salt every time. Automatic.
Also, Tip #2: Don’t try too many new things at once. I used half molasses and half agave, but being new at molasses, I didn’t realize the taste of the hearty sweetener is very overpowering. Next batch, I will stick to the recipe, enjoy MB’s original idea, and then modify per taste!
Eden Passante says
This looks so amazing! Those flavors together are everything!
Megan says
Great recipe! I am making this for a LOT of peeps. A little food-science questions…do you think adding salt makes the ice cream melt faster? Obviously I’m comparing my ice cream to my frozen sidewalk and pouring salt on it :) Thanks!
Julia says
This looks amazing! Going to try it this weekend. Do you reckon you could use honey instead of the maple syrup? Maple syrup is outrageously expensive in Australia :(
Sonja says
wow, your ice cream recipes look all so delicious! Is it possible to make them without an ice cream maker? Has anyone tried that yet? Hugs from Germany
Hi Sonja! It’s possible to make this (and other recipes) without an ice cream maker. Simply blend, pour into a freezer-safe container and cover with foil. Every hour for 5-6 hours, remove from freezer and stir/whisk to incorporate air. Good luck!
Neko says
Could this be made with soya cream(like Alpro single cream) instead of coconut cream? I get a bad reaction to coconut milk/cream, and then I also don’t like the taste. Thanks in advance.
Arnay says
I am going to make this for sure, I can not subscribe as your system does not say my email address is valid, it is btw..
lottie says
this ice cream looks delicious! so much so that I bought all the ingredients and soaked the cashews before reading that I need an ice cream maker… silly I know. Any chance you think I could get away with making it without one?
aparna jain says
Can I use coconut butter instead of coconut milk? I want to avoid using those cans.
I don’t think so…
nat says
Hi! I always enjoy your recipes SO much…I love that they usually use ingredients that are super easy to find; thanks for sharing all this! Can’t wait for your book!
I have a question. where I live, peanut ice cream is really popular (and so incredibly delicious) and I’ve been craving it for YEARS! I’ve looked for vegan recipes, but I only find peanut butter ones….my question (finally!) is: do you think that if I subbed cashews with peanuts, I’d be able to taste the peanuts? Or would it be better to use this recipe as base and just add peanuts to the mix?
thanks in advance!!! ♡
Hmm, I’m not sure but I think it could work~ Let me know if you give it a try!!
CC says
Wo! It looks amazing! I am pregnant and my husband doesn’t allow me to have ice cream. But summer is coming. I can’t live without ice cream! Is there any possible you could record a vedio for us to learn how to make this ice cream perfectly like you did? Because I am a bad cooker :(
Carla says
“I am pregnant and my husband doesn’t allow me to have ice cream. ”
1. Why in the world?
2. What kind of relationship do you have??
3. WHY???
Jessica says
Just made this and it tastes amazing (: I do have a problem/question though… Does your cashew cream/milk come out gritty? I can feel extremely tiny pieces of nut as I eat the ice cream, which is not ideal. I prefer creamy/soft. I’ve actually tried to make vegan ice cream with cashews before with the same results :(
I made sure the cashews were raw.
I soaked them overnight plus the hours I was at work.
I used my ninja blender to blend them at the highest speed (blended, tasted, noticed it was gritty, then tried two more times)
Is it supposed to be gritty? What am I doing wrong?
Thanks <3
That has to do with the blender. Ninjas, in my experience, do not puree into a cream. I know it’s not likely you’ll want to return or exchange, but I highly recommend a Vitamix (splurge) or this one from Kitchenaid.
Shawna says
Looks great! Is there a vegan substitute for coconut cream? I tend to taste coconut even in very small quantities.
Just swap it for almond or rice milk.
Dolce says
I followed the recipe with all the listed ingredients but my ice cream became somehow crumbly and wasn’t scoopable. To scoop it, I needed to not soften but “melt” the ice cream. Any advice? The taste was great, though.
Hmm, let it thaw a little more? And use a hot scoop!
Polly says
Dolce, crumbly ice cream can be caused by over churning. Stop when the mixture is the texture of soft serve.
Jordan says
This looks so good, and I’m getting ready to try it, but my husband bought me roasted cashews by mistake. Do you have any idea whether it will work with them (instead of the raw)? If need be, I’ll hold out for another trip to the store, but it looks so good…
Unfortunately, I don’t think so but it may still be worth a try! Roasting removes some of the natural oil, so it may not be as creamy. Let me know if you still give it a try, Jordan!
fannar bjorgvinsson says
what is the function of putting so much cashews in there, would it not be as firm and rich if used only fullfat coconut milk ? you def have the most beautiful vegan icecream out there. I would love a technical explanation on why using cashews instead of just full fat coconuts? :)
It makes the ultimate creamy, decadent ice cream. Just coconut cream doesn’t yield as creamy a result! I find the best ice creams to be a mix of cashews + coconut milk! Hope that helps.
Kelley says
Oh my gosh, Salt & Straw!!!! I’ve missed that place ever since we moved out of Portland. I will be making this recipe as soon as I can!
It’s so great right? Hope you enjoy this, Kelley!
Jackie says
I want to make this but I don’t have a ice cream maker! What would you suggest- besides going out and buying one
Brigid says
The weather’s warming up lovely here in Wales UK, so I’m getting out the ice cream equipment, I can’t wait to make this one!! My kids share my love of ice cream but obviously I don’t want to feed them junk too often, so this sort of recipe is perfect.
Can you try to invent a coconut raspberry ripple ice cream?? I think coconut and raspberry are one of those heavenly marriages.
Ooh, great idea! Added to the list!!!
Sarita says
This looks amazing! My cashews are soaking and tomorrow evening this will be desert in Southern Burgundy, France. I am so pleased to have found your recipes – vegans (and vegan supplies) are very rare in rural France so I’m desperate for good (simple) recipes. I can’t wait to try this.
Amy says
My Mom forwarded this to me from her newsletter. Being a mostly raw vegan, how excited was I to see this! Hubby & I made it for a party this past weekend and EVERYONE LOVED IT! All guests were non-vegan and they could not believe how good this was. Thank you for your kitchen genius with this!
Mary says
Hello!
This looks AMAZING!
I cannot eat cashews or any syrup, so I was wondering if I could SUB them for something else? Stevia for sweetness and almonds maybe?….or something else?
Thanx a lot!
You could definitely sweeten with stevia to taste. And for the cashews, double the coconut milk! It will definitely affect the texture, but I think you’ll still like it!
Maggie says
Just wondering…What kind of ice cream Maker/churner do you recommend??
Find all of the links to our kitchenware here!
Find all of our kitchen essentials here!
Hillary says
Thank you, I made this recipe tonight and couldn’t wait to dig in! It was delicious! I’m not vegan, but it is always good to experiment with healthier approaches to ice cream. :) This recipe is so creamy and sweet! I will make it again, definitely.
Rachel says
You mentioned the original ice cream has chocolate chunks in it but you didn’t put them in. I think they would be a perfect addition to this recipe! Would you just chop up some chocolate? Or are the chunks more fudgy and brownie-like?
They’re ganache-like candy bar bits. So what I would do is make some ganache (pour 1/4 cup warm almond milk over 3/4 cup chopped dark chocolate, wait for 2 minutes, then stir until fully melted (microwaving it doesn’t quite melt). You can add a bit of melted coconut oil to the mix for ultra creamy texture. Then, when you’re putting it into the pan, I’d drizzle the still-warm ganache over the ice cream in layers. Good luck!!
dibster says
Looks amazing !
Can I substitute honey for agave ? Would I use the same amount ?
Thanks !
Yes!
Ashley says
Soaking my cashews as I type! So excited to taste this later this week. I listened to Jess Livelys podcast on a solo road trip and so glad she interviewed you! A lot of these recipes have given me much needed inspiration since becoming vegan earlier this year!
Ashley
Ria says
Perfect treat! YUM
Natty says
This looks absolutely amazing! I’m in a suburb of Vancouver (BC not Washington) so I can relate regarding the cherry blossoms ect. I definitely want to try this. 382 cals is a pretty big chunk of my daily limit. Do you think it would work with Light coconut milk?
Annie says
Love all your vegan ice cream recipes. We made the chai ice cream the other day and it turned out amazing. Looking forward to making this one this week!
Extra bonus on having a minimalist philosophy on recipes without the junk!
Jen says
Hi from still very cold and miserable but with tiny signs of green Scotland!
This looks completely lush. But I don’t have, nor do I have space to keep, an ice cream maker. Usually ice creams can be made manually, freezing, removing, beating, freezing, removing, beating ad infinitum (!) to achieve the same effect. Do you think that would work here?
Amanda Templeman says
I just tried making this and it was grainy :( ..does that mean I didn’t soak my nuts long enough?
Kathleen says
I finally got my ice cream maker and this was my first try. My cashews didn’t liquefy, so my ice cream turned out grainy too. Any suggestions on how to create a smoother texture? It always looks so easy in the photos!
The taste is good, I’m just off on the texture.
Clover says
My dates that I bought are huge compared to others. Do you have a volume of dates recommendation so I don’t use too much. thanks.
renata helm says
Hi! I am addicted to this nice place you guys have here. ;D Even bought the book and printed. Had to print it <3
Is it possible to do it without an ice cream machine? Like you did on no churn vegan chocolate ice cream??
Lavinnia says
Was just wondering which brand of ice cream maker you use. I’ve never owned one before, but I want whatever you have!
Find all our kitchen tools here!
Laure says
This may be futile, but I really hate the taste of coconut – is there an alternative non-dairy ingredient? We use a lot of almond and cashew milk, but they are both pretty low-fat.
Thanks!
You can sub olive oil for the coconut oil, and either almond or cashew milk for the coconut milk!
Abby says
Hi Dana!
Can you recommend an ice cream churn?
Thanks!!
Abby
Jennifer C. says
I only seem to have a can of TJs coconut cream on hand. Do you think I could use it, or would it be too thick?
Aveary says
I was wondering the same thing! Did you end up using the coconut cream instead? how did it turn out?
Kirsty says
Yum! Looks so good, thanks for the recipe :)
Erin @ The Spiffy Cookie says
Arg! My Trader Joes has been out of coconut oil, milk and cream for weeks now, they say it’s due to a strike in CA. Must find…
Ha! Fight for your coconut rights, girl!
May says
Hm… this looks de-li-cous! Ever thought about an avocado-lime version? I might try making one soon :)
Libby says
So cool! That flavor is my favorite at Salt & Straw, so this is really amazing to see your version of it.
You get me! You you love this version, Libby!
Ashley-Marie says
Hi Dana! I love this recipe (and all your ice cream recipes!) but I don’t have an ice cream machine. What kind do you have or recommend?
Also, not related but equally interesting, do you calculate the nutrition facts yourself or do you have a plugin for that? I love that you include them for each recipe!
Thanks,
Ashley-Marie
Hi Ashley! I use caloriecount.com to calculate my recipe nutrition information. As for the ice cream maker, find all info on our kitchen equipment here!
Ashley-Marie says
Thanks!
Marlene says
What ice cream maker do you have? This looks amazing!!
Find it here!
Abby says
These photos are gorgeous, Dana! I literally can’t stop staring at ’em.
And this ice cream!?!? OMG amazing. I NEED. :D
Ha! Thanks Abby! Hope you give it a go.
Sarah | Broma Bakery says
I would ice cream with you any day. Especially if it mean sea salt and caramel ice cream! Enjoy the spring for all of us!
Seana Turner says
The only thing that looks better to me than some salted caramel ice cream is the image of trees in bloom outside of your window that popped into my mind as I read your words. This seems MONTHS away out here in CT, where we had yet another fresh batch of 5+inches of snow last night. Sigh…
So sorry! Take heart. Spring is around the corner! In the meantime, ice cream!
Lisa | Mummy Made.It says
Love love love it!!! What a great flavour. Date caramel is awesome
Madeline | My Fitter Life says
Is this a dream or an actual recipe for amazing ice-cream, lol
haha, actual recipe! too kind.
Iris says
Can you make this without an ice cream maker? Like how you made the vegan chocolate ice cream? That was perfection! I hope to make this, too.
Hmm, because it’s so thick/rich you might be able to get away without churning. I’d recommend taking it out of the freezer several times while it’s firming up and whipping it with a whisk or beater. Good luck!
Iria says
Good point! Thanks! :)
Jessica Charlotte says
Oh delicious! I love seasalt caramel and coconut. Combining them into ice cream is a dream! Thank you for sharing this recipe. X
Jess X
chasinglifeandme.blogspot.co.uk
Lobna says
Hey there :).
I was wondering if there is a way i could make this without the icecreammaker? I unfortunatly don’t have one.
Leslie says
Best ice cream ever! I have made every ice cream recipe you have posted, they are all delicious (even if you don’t regularly eat vegan). Thanks again for all your yummy posts
So great! Thanks for sharing, Leslie!
Caitlin says
Hi, I’m curious what kind of ice cream maker you use — is it the Kitchen Aid attachment for the stand mixers? If so are you having any problems with the blue coolant leaking out of the bowl? I am on the fence about purchasing it because I’ve heard bad reviews but I’ve also heard it can be from washing the bowl with warm water when it is still cold which can cause cracking. Great recipe..looking forward to trying it out if I take the plunge and get a maker!
See the above comment with a link! I love ours. Good luck!
Holly Clark says
oh my this looks incredible!!
Have been looking for the perfect recipe to try out my ice cream maker!
Think I just found it!!!
Thank you
Holly
X
Let me know how it goes, Holly!
Toni Marie says
I love salted caramel and this looks so delicious! :)
Sally B. says
Salt and Straw is amazing! We were there twice while visiting friends there and were thrilled when they opened up a shop in LA. Feel free to figure out how to make the lavender honey as well!
haha, challenge accepted!
Sally B. says
Hurrah! I wish you the best of luck!
Elaine says
For the lavender honey you could start with your basic vanilla ice cream and add honey and use lavender esscential oil . You would have to get a pure oil like Young Living oils. I have used these oils for baking and for ice creams. Also for massages. ( I am a massage Therapist) You only need a few drops . Just taste and adjust. you can also use the peppermint oil for mint chocolate chip. Or butter mint white chocolate ice cream. yummy
Neeli says
Dana, first of all, I have to say that I love your blog and have saved several recipes that I want to try. I’m not even a vegan, but lawd have mercy your recipes look so good! I would seriously put a hurtin’ on this ice cream.
Thanks Neeli! I love creating recipes that even meat eaters love! So glad to hear you’ve enjoyed our recipes so much! Thanks for sharing.
Sherry Ann says
Is it okay to substitute raisins for the dates? I have never made ice cream before and I want to try this recipe! I have an aversion to the flavor of dates, but I do enjoy the flavor of raisins.
Hmm, I would think so but it will definitely affect the flavor. Let me know if you try it!!
Deb says
What kind of dates do you use?
Marty says
I am looking to buy a new ice cream maker. Mine does not work. Could you recommend one that works.
Sure! Find a link to ours here!
Ellen Lederman says
I am so making this! Thanks, Dana—since I may never get to Portland—Atlanta doesn’t have much vegan ice cream, so I may it myself.
A silly question, but I think you won’t mind my asking it. In this, like all other salted caramel recipes, the amount of salt is really very small. Did you experiment with a higher amount of salt to up the salt factor? Or are you just supposed to barely notice the saltiness?
You can play with it to get the right amount of saltiness! I’ve tasted some that are WAY too salty and some that are barely detectable. I think the recommended amount should provide the right balance!
Camila says
yummm
Molly Robinson says
oh my – that ice-cream look incredible! It is making my mouth water and it isn’t even 9 o’clock in the morning! It looks so creamy and delicious! Gorgeous photos also :: M x
Matea says
I want this ice cream so badly right now! It’s still a little on the chilly side where I live, but who cares? Ice cream is for every season!
AMEN
Cece Leskova says
Oh yuuuum, this looks so good!
katie @ butterlust says
I was JUST at a local ice cream shop with my lactose intolerant boyfriend wondering how in the heck they get their coconut-based vegan ice cream so creamy! I tend to find that even with just the separated coconut cream it always turns out a little icy — but cashew cream is brilliant! Can’t wait to try it!
How funny! I’m not sure how ice cream shops do it, but I find the combination of soaked cashews, full fat coconut milk and coconut oil to do the trick!
Estela says
Literally gets the best results!!! I love that you use cashews, i’m not a huge fan of the coconut only bases. Thank you so mucch!
Heather Mason @NuttyNutrition says
mmm, this looks amazing! Salty and sweet is the best combo!
ines oliveira says
I think I’ve fallen for your ice cream! Who cares if it is snowing outside!? – and, indeed, it is – I want a double scoop one right now!
Ha! Sorry to tempt! Hope you give this one a try, despite the cold weather!
Medha @ Whisk & Shout says
I never would have thought to use date caramel in ice cream! I would have totally gravitated towards the sugar base… this is so much smarter and healthier! Looks so yum, I love your insta :)
It’s the best! Hope you give it a try, Medha!
Ashley Murphy, RD says
Oh my goodness I want!! This looks amazing!
Mindy Galvan says
If I wanted to use store bought cashew milk instead if making my own, how much should I use?
Emily @ Life on Food says
just like I eat soup in the soup I have ice cream in the winter. this looks amazing!! I am just jealous you have spring temperatures in the northwest. we are getting more snow! the ice cream will make it better though.
Boo! so sorry about the snow. Maybe if you make this ice cream it will summon spring!
Anna says
I need this machine!! I don’t think I’ll be able to wait until summer to do this <3
Mabel @ Ma Bella Vita says
This makes me want to run and go get myself an ice cream maker. How delicious-looking and Im sure it tastes as good as it looks.
Firegirl says
Hi there! I love tue sound of this ice cream, but unfortunately my little one is allergic to various nuts (ok with coconuts though). Do you have any suggestions of how I could replace the nuts? Thanks!
See the above comment!
Valérie says
Love the recipe and it is the perfect treat for the sunny spring weather we are just having in the south of Sweden! Caramel and salt are always a good combination.
//Valérie
Ooh, Sweden – nice! Hoping to visit there later this year!
Jocelyn (Grandbaby cakes) says
This looks absolutely fantastic. I would like to try this but I have an allergy to tree nuts. What can I sub instead of the cashews or can they be omitted?
Hmm, you could probably omit it and double up on coconut milk – just make sure it’s full fat. Also add some cornstarch or arrowroot and twice the vanilla to cut down on crystallization!
Mel says
Hi Dana! How much starch should we use? Thanks!
Lena says
Cashews are not tree nuts. You should find out if you’re allergic to cashews as well. Different allergen than tree nuts!
Cassie says
This ice cream looks amazing!!! Love it!!
Elizabeth at Pineapples and Polka Dots says
Oh my! This looks delicious! I love trying new ice cream recipes, especially ones that don’t require eggs. This one is going on my list for sure!
Laura ~ Raise Your Garden says
I totally agree, if you’re looking to avoid eggs, it’s tricky. Plus most vegan recipes (especially for ice cream) are so complicated, and have SO many ingredients that I just give up! I don’t even attempt. This actually looks pretty easy too.
Thanks ladies! Hope you love this one!
Agnes says
Made birthday cakes in feb for both my daughter & 98 yr young friend, with very similar ingredients. The result ?FABULOUS??LOOKING ForWARD to trying you version of it?????
Kayla says
Actually, I find vegan ice cream recipes easy as most are made with a high speed blender & just a few ingredients.